U.S. Attorney slams "keyboard warriors" signaling support for Gadsden mosque firebombing

Phil Williams, U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of Alabama, on Monday harshly criticized social media users showing support for the arson suspect.

Phill Williams mosque video
Phil Williams, U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of Alabama, criticizes "keyboard warriors" supporting the firebombing of a Gadsden mosque in a Facebook video on Monday.Facebook

An APR news article posted to Facebook Monday detailing an arrest in the firebombing of a Gadsden mosque generated more than 4,500 comments—most of them along the lines of "He was fishing with me at the time" or "let's buy him a beer."

Endless similar comments could be found on social media posts from outlets across the state—and even the FBI Birmingham Facebook page—as news of the arrest spread.

Those comments prompted Phil Williams, U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of Alabama, to respond on Monday with a video criticizing the "keyboard warriors."

"Keyboard Warriors who summon up their keyboard courage and begin typing out their applause, calling him a hero, and encouraging more of the same actions do nothing to preserve a well-ordered society," Williams said in the post. "It is disheartening to see that many people laughingly say that this man deserves a free round at the bar more than he deserves jail time for attempting to burn down a building that may well have contained people.

"Think about what you say on social media. Would you say it if you were face to face? If not, then question yourself as to whether it is worth saying at all. Keyboard courage is not really courage. It is cowardice behind the virtual anonymity of social media, and it is the breakdown of social discourse in this country."

Williams said his office learned Friday that the mosque had been the target of a firebombing attack, triggering an immediate coordination with the FBI including the approval of a $20,000 reward for information leading to an arrest, Within 48 hours, law enforcement took Daniel Timothy Mason Black into custody on charges of second-degree arson and possession or manufacture of a destructive device.

The firebombing and resulting online vitriol comes in an environment where political leaders and far-right influencers have stoked concerns about Islam in Alabama, including from hosts at the podcast Phil Williams founded.

Rightside Radio host Allison Sinclair—previously Williams' co-host—had been posting steadily for the past week about the Auburn Islamic Center's plan to build a new mosque in the city, as some of the same culprits who later showed support for whoever committed the mosque attack filled her comment section with dismay.

While Williams was bashing the comments in his post on Monday, Sinclair posted on X that the 1991 Muslim Brotherhood explanatory memorandum shows that Muslims are "actively executing a plan to conquer America" and warning that "when Muslims take over there won't be a First Amendment."

"We'll all be dead of paying a jizya tax or muslim," Sinclair posted.

CAIR-Alabama called on political leaders to change the way they talk about Islam to help lower the temperature.

"We welcome the arrest made in connection with this arson attack on the Gadsden Islamic Society and thank both the FBI and the Gadsden Police Department for their swift and professional actions in this case," said CAIR-Alabama Staff Attorney A. Britton O'Shields. "We also reiterate our call for political leaders, including Governor-Elect Tuberville, to stop stoking anti-Muslim hate, condemn this attack, and protect every community's civil and religious rights."