Auburn officials address recent furor over mosque expansion
While online critics pushed the issue to the forefront, public comments at the council meeting were split.
The mostly online furor over the potential expansion of an Auburn mosque spilled over into a real public forum on Tuesday as citizens expressed concerns or support to the Auburn City Council.
There have been rumbles about the proposed expansion of the Auburn Islamic Center online for quite some time, with the discussion reaching a fever pitch over the past couple of weeks. Rightside Radio host Allison Sinclair has beat the drum on the issue, while painting Islam as a violent religion by nature and claiming Muslims seek to take over American society.
Mayor Ron Anders took a moment at the Auburn City Council meeting Tuesday night to clear up the city’s role in the mosque expansion, which is minimal.
“The Auburn Islamic Center has owned the property (at Mill Creek) for 12 years and has recently submitted plans to construct a mosque there within the rural zoning district,” Anders said. “The current Auburn Islamic Center on Armstrong Center has provided a space for its congregants to go for 36 years, having been established in 1990. Under Auburn’s zoning ordinance, mosques are classified as churches, and churches are granted the right to develop without approval from the planning commission or the city council within a rural zoning district.”
Instead, the plans were reviewed by the city’s Development Review Team, and recently gained approval.
“The mosque was treated just like any development—even those you’ve seen here tonight, it was treated the same way,” Anders said. “I would say anecdotally that if you were to talk to any of our developers and builders in our community, Auburn is the most difficult place to develop and build in all of Alabama; and the mosque faced very bit of that.”
Even critics of the expansion have mostly accepted that there is little the city could have done to stop the expansion—unlike in Hoover, where the need for special zoning allowed heat from residents and political leaders all the way up to U.S. Senator Tommy Tuberville to influence the denial of a proposed relocation and expansion of the Islamic Academy of Alabama.
Those people angry about the mosque expansion pointed to the land’s ownership by the North American Islamic Trust, citing its involvement as an unindicted co-conspirator in the 2008 Holy Land Foundation case involving the financing of Hamas.
City Attorney Paul Clark addressed that piece of the development during Tuesday’s council meeting as well.
“It has been widely reported on at social media outlets—it’s been alleged, let me say that—that the North American Islamic Trust has ties to terrorist organizations,” Clark said. “I did do some research to try to discover the basis of those assertions that have been made on social media about the North American Islamic Trust.
“It appears that in 2007, the U.S. Attorney’s Office in the Northern District of Texas criminally prosecuted an organization called the Holy Land Foundation for Relief and Development in federal court there in Texas. In the process of that criminal trial, the U.S. Attorney’s Office filed a document naming 240 individuals and entities as unindicted co-conspirators in that case, including the North American Islamic Trust. It appears in reviewing the court records, that was done to allow some evidence to be presented in that criminal case that would have otherwise been prohibited by the hearsay rule ...
“What is very clear in reviewing that case from 2007—which is almost 20 years ago now—is that the North American Islamic Trust was never charged with a crime, they were never charged by any grand jury, they were never convicted of any crime. And even after that trial was over involving the Holy Land Foundation in north Texas, the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals ... found that the U.S. Attorney’s Office had actually breached the Fifth Amendment rights of the North American Islamic Trust, and all the other unindicted co-conspirators, by naming them publicly in that case in a forum in which they had no ability to provide a defense to those assertions that they were unindicted co-conspirators.
“So while it is true that the North American Islamic Trust was named as an unindicted co-conspirator in a criminal case in the federal courts in Texas in 2007, it is also true that that body has never been charged with, indicted for or convicted of a crime stemming from the allegations in that case, or from any other case that I could find in the 19 years since that decision was made.”
Clark said the city does not have the authority to investigate the financing behind any of its developments and that only the state and federal governments would be empowered to do that. Investigating the financing of city developments is something that simply does not happen, he said.
The uproar comes as a man firebombed a Gadsden mosque just last week. While no motive has been given yet in that case, comments flooded social media stories about the arrest offering to buy the man a beer, or cheekily providing an alibi in the apparent furtherance of violence against Islamic facilities.
Public comments by residents at the meeting were split between criticism of the mosque expansion—primarily fueled by concerns over the practice of Islam—and residents upset at the vitriol that has arisen against the mosque.
“There’s a hill to die on—and this is mine,” said resident Barry Jones. “This is not about God vs a false prophet, this not about Republican vs Democrat ... this is about an ideology that wants to wipe us off the face of the Earth.”






























