Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?


Pro-Life and Pro-Choice Offer Differing Views on Bills’ Passage

By Brandon Moseley
Alabama Political Reporter

On Tuesday, February 4 the Alabama House of Representatives passed four bills aimed at better regulating abortions which are performed in the State of Alabama.  Pro-Life groups praised passage of the landmark legislation while abortion supporters denounced the legislation that was spearheaded by the Alabama House Republican Caucus.

Alabama Citizens for Life said in a written statement that they, “…are thankful to Republican Majority Leader Speaker Mike Hubbard for the Alabama State House today’s passage of 4 prolife bills.”

Meanwhile, the Vice President of Public Policy for Planned Parenthood Southeast, Nikema Williams, said in her statement, “These bills reflect an extreme and out-of-touch agenda that does nothing to make women healthier.”

The Executive Director of the ACLU of Alabama, Susan Watson, said of the passage of the abortion bills in the State House of Representatives,  “Although the fetal heartbeat bill is the most controversial, it should be noted that all of the bills present grave consequences to women.”

Director Watson said, “All of these bills are another attempt by politicians to own a woman’s body. Reproductive health choices should only be made by the woman, her doctor, her family and her faith—not by the opinions and faiths of unqualified elected officials.  They’re not in the exam room and each woman’s story is different.”

One of the Bills passed by the House was HB 494, which strengthens Alabama’s parental consent law.  The bill was sponsored by Representative Mike Jones (R) from Andalusia.  Rep. Jones said, “This bill deals with parental consent which has already been upheld by the courts.”  HB494 toughens parental consent requirements for minors seeking an abortion.”

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Alabama Citizens for Life said in their statement,

“Parental consent legislation closes a loophole that has made Alabama an embarrassment since several video expose’ of sexual abuse cover up in Birmingham was discovered…The now temporarily closed Planned Parenthood abortion mill in Birmingham’s director was caught on audio tape by Lila Rose who posed as an underage minor seeking an abortion asked that her parents not find out. To which the Planned Parenthood employee replied they could ‘bend the rules’ meaning not even notify much less receive parental consent.  This consistent disregard for alabama parental rights laws also showed up in ADPH surveys where none of the minor girls charts had parental consent forms signed by a parent.”  Lila Rose, who was portraying to be a 14year old girl pregnant by a 31 year old boyfriend.  Center staff suggested that someone other than a parent or legal guardian could give consent for a minor to have an abortion.”

Cheryl Ciamarra, the ACLs Board Director to the national right to life committee said, “This common sense amendment will begin to put into effect the original intent of the law when passed in the late 90’s.”

Planned Parenthood complained, “HB 494 would add significant barriers to services for minors for whom it may be difficult or even dangerous to discuss sexuality with their parents.”

HB 493, sponsored by Rep. Kurt Wallace (R) from Maplesville, would require that a family that finds out that their child has been diagnosed with a fetal abnormality be given information about Perinatal Hospice and requires a 48 waiting period before that child can be aborted.  HB493 informs a woman whose unborn child has a lethal fetal anomaly of perinatal hospice services.

Rep. Kurt Wallace said on Facebook, “Woooo Hoooo! It was great day for the unborn children in the great State of Alabama tonight! All four of the Pro-Life bills easily passed the House and are now headed for the Senate. As most of you know, I carried HB493, the Perinatal Hospice Information Act, it passed by a margin of 73 – 24.”

The House also passed HB 489, sponsored by Rep. Ed Henry (R) from Decatur, the bill requires that a woman who wishes to have an abortion must be notified of the risk of having an abortion and that that waiting period be extended from 24 hours to 48 hours.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

“Forcing a woman to wait even longer before she receives medical care does nothing to improve her health,” said Nikema Williams.

Alabama Citizens for Life said that their, “Primary objective for legislation has always been public education on life issues particularly giving objective information to those mothers considering an abortion decision.  ACL would like The women’s right to know amendment to include the mothers be given a list of where they could obtain a free ultrasound.  Seeing their actual babies face is the most objective information possible.  Sidewalk counselors report women are not being given the ADPH. Developed booklets with the baby development stages, which is why we have proposed a website so women can see that information in the privacy of their own homes while they consider their options.”

The Alabama House also passed HB 490, the Fetal Heartbeat Act, sponsored by state Representative Mary Sue McClurkin (R) from Indian Springs.  Rep. McClurkin said that the legislation, “Would make it unlawful for a physician to perform an abortion on a pregnant woman if a heartbeat is detected on an unborn child.”  The bill also requires that abortion clinic keep documentation showing that the fetal heartbeat test was performed.  The Fetal Heart Beat bill passed the House of Representatives 73 to 29.

Planned Parenthood argued that, “HB 490 would restrict abortion on pregnancies as early as 6 weeks — long before some women even realize they are pregnant.”

Bill Klein, the President of Alabama citizens for life said that he is especially pleased with the heartbeat bill! although he would like to see the exception for fetal anomalies amendment which was added by Joe Hubbard in the House Health Committee removed in the Senate as disabled babies lives deserve respect and should not be discriminated against.  Every innocent human life is precious and one life isn’t worth less than another due to perceived quality of life issues.

Susan Watson said, “We may not all feel the same about abortion, but it is important that we support a woman’s health and well-being.”

Ms. Williams said, “These bad bills put obstacle after obstacle between a woman and her doctor.  They waste taxpayer’s money and our legislator’s time. Our elected officials should be championing health care for Alabamians — not restricting it.”

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Watson said, “On another note, when it comes down to litigation, it is going to cost the State dearly.  We can’t fix the conditions and over-crowding in our prisons; improve our schools; or even give teachers the raises that the governor is really fighting for.  If we can’t afford such simple things that effect hundreds of thousands of Alabamians, how can the State afford lawsuits of this magnitude?  Economically, it would be disastrous.  It’s callous and reckless behavior that proves that politician’s aren’t conscious of Alabama citizens or the financial catastrophe that this state is in.”

Rep. Butler said on Facebook, “They keep saying these bills will wind up in court! That’s exactly what needs to happen. That is how we get Roe V Wade overturned.”

Alabama Speaker of the House Mike Hubbard (R) from Auburn said in a written statement, “As long as liberal Supreme Court justices hold up Roe V. Wade as the law of the land, we will dare defend the right to life in Alabama. And what a difference four years makes. With a Republican Majority, we have reversed course and right to life legislation is not only prioritized it is passed.”  Hubbard vowed that the House Republican Caucus, “Will continue our efforts to advance the culture of life in our great State.


Brandon Moseley is a former reporter at the Alabama Political Reporter.

More from APR


The book was written by an anti-abortion minister who signed a statement in 1993 justifying the murder of an abortion provider.


Two separate suits have been filed challenging threats of prosecution against such individuals.


The bus tour kicks off on June 24, one year after the reversal of Roe v. Wade.


Opponents have criticized the centers as deceptive faith-based organizations that, when abortion was legal, pushed women away from the practice.