Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Featured Opinion

Bentley backs Trumpcare, Jesus wept

By Josh Moon
Alabama Political Reporter

America first!*

(*excluding: the poor, the disabled, the elderly, minorities who don’t believe slaves were immigrants and non-Christians)

This is the agenda of the Trump administration and today’s Republican Party. It is an agenda that has been lifted straight from Alabama conservatives, who long ago crafted laws and regulations to benefit the rich white male above all others.

On Wednesday, Alabama’s top rich, white, male, Gov. Robert Bentley, returned from a D.C. meeting with Trump officials about health care, and he was a happy man.

That’s because what Bentley heard was a positive reply when he suggested cruel solutions to Alabama’s Medicaid funding woes.

Bentley, a doctor by trade, said he was supportive of the new Trumpcare plan that Republicans in Congress are pushing, because, he said, congressmen made promises to him. Among those promises, as reported by The Montgomery Advertiser, was charging Medicaid recipients with co-pays and forcing a work requirement on them.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

If you know even basic information about Alabama Medicaid, you know those ideas are incredibly stupid.

It is essentially impossible for a healthy, childless adult to qualify for Medicaid. Over half of the recipients are children. Another large portion is the impoverished elderly. Another is disabled people.

That leaves a small percentage of Medicaid recipients who qualify for the program because they are the impoverished guardian of an eligible child.

To be eligible, the yearly household income for that adult-plus-child can’t exceed $3,000. That’s $250 per month. For two people.

Let me put that in a way Bentley can understand: In six months, these people earn about what it cost to fly your wallet to the beach.

Is forcing a $20 co-pay out of a person hauling in roughly $60 per week really solving a budgetary crisis?

And requiring more than eight hours of work per week would, of course, make that person ineligible for Medicaid.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Taking the smallest percentage of recipients, implementing meaningless requirements and then paying for them to receive care at ERs doesn’t seem like the best solution.

Who knew health care could be so hard?

What’s even harder – and often requiring of comical acts of contortion – is the reconciliation of such callous, greedy governance and the teachings of Jesus Christ. That dude loved some poor people, and he was pretty clear in his directives to clothe the poor, feed the hungry and care for the afflicted.

Yet, we still have people lining up behind a health care plan – Trumpcare – that will leave millions of poor Americans, and hundreds of thousands of poor Alabamians, without insurance coverage.

According to a report prepared by Manatt Health and provided to the state legislature and governor, Alabama will be one of the hardest hit states under Trumpcare, should it pass. That’s mainly because the state has no wiggle room, since it already has the lowest Medicaid threshold in the country and the third-lowest per-recipient Medicaid expenditures.

There’s nothing left to cut…other than the lives of poor people.

Which, if we’re being honest, is the GOP health care plan in a nutshell. People in the richest country on earth will die from treatable ailments if this plan passes.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

I’m so tired of people pretending that there’s a super-secret health care plan out there, other than single-payer, that will cover more people, lower costs and allow flexibility.

There’s not.

Again, this is basic math and common sense. We’re all in this health care game together, which means we’re all affected by each other.

If my neighbor has a heart attack and open-heart surgery, doesn’t pay the bill because he has no insurance and claims bankruptcy, I am going to pay that bill through my higher premiums.

That’s why our premiums in the pre-Obamacare years were jumping by 200 percent in eight years – because when the 45 million who then lacked insurance suffered illnesses or accidents, they went to the ER and got care they couldn’t possibly receive.

When the insurance companies booted folks with chronic illnesses off their rolls, the people still got treatment, but we paid their bill.

All Obamacare did was force the coverage of those high-cost people, so we could budget for their care and finally get them some cheaper preventative care, and force younger, healthier people onto the rolls so we could use their unspent premiums to offset the care of the chronically ill.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Outside of a single-payer option, it’s the only plan that can work.

And the only option for ending the mandates and lowering prices is to boot people off the insurance rolls. Or, as Bentley put it to me the other day, the 24 million expected to lose coverage under Trumpcare “are no longer forced to buy insurance.”

It’s freedom, he said.

That’s the one freedom Alabama politicians will ensure for the poor of this State.

The freedom to die.


Josh Moon is an investigative reporter and featured columnist at the Alabama Political Reporter with years of political reporting experience in Alabama. You can email him at [email protected] or follow him on Twitter.

More from APR

Featured Opinion

For a long time now in Alabama, we have let ignorance be our guide. The bill has been steep.


It’s time for Alabama policymakers to come together and forge a solution to the state’s mental health crisis.


Judicial override previously allowed judges to usurp a jury and sentence someone to death.


More than 230 supporters of Alabama Arise Action convened at the Statehouse in Montgomery.