Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Featured Opinion

Letter to Gov. Ivey: There’s a way out of the Confederate monuments mess

By Josh Moon
Alabama Political Reporter

Dear Gov. Kay Ivey,

Hello there, Governor. Hope you’re well. And I mean that – I wouldn’t dare wish illness on anyone in this State after what those in your political party have done to healthcare around here.

But I’m not writing today about healthcare. That’s an incredibly complicated issue (who knew, right!) that would take far too long. Thankfully, my subject matter is much easier.

Monuments. The Confederate kind.

Actually, I’m writing to give you a bit of an out on this one. A way to slide stupid ol’ SB60, the Alabama Memorial Preservation Act, into your pocket and still show your face at the Montgomery Country Club.

Because, as luck would have it, SB60 is the classic example of poorly-intentioned, not very bright lawmakers trying desperately to conceal the fact that they were trying to do something that they know is callous and hurtful.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

In other words, the Alabama Legislature was trying to be slick and pass a bill to protect offensive Confederate monuments, except those same lawmakers were also oddly afraid to come right out and just do that, so they tried to sell it as a bill protecting all monuments.

Which, they soon discovered, is not as easy as you might think, since people name a lot of stuff for a lot of people and sometimes there are good reasons to tear stuff down or move things.

So, they had to also account for that.

And, well, since most of the time these guys have trouble enough balancing their intentions, the law and the English language when crafting these pieces of Legislation, you can likely imagine that this whole thing went rather poorly.

At one point, SB60 essentially turned the entire state into a historic district. Another incarnation protected every monument built starting when it was finished.

The debates over it were just as embarrassing.

Like the argument that removing monuments to the men who led a traitorous secession against America is “erasing” history. That makes no sense.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Honoring and respecting history is building the 9-11 museum at the site of the attacks – to remember what occurred, honor the dead and heroes, and to preserve the memory for future generations.

But the folks in New York aren’t erecting statues of the terrorists who flew the planes.

Likewise, no one’s trying to tear down the first White House of the Confederacy museum or remove the Civil War soldiers’ memorial.

Because, like the 9-11 museum, those are places where the history and complicated issues of the Civil War can be accurately and appropriately delivered, and where necessary and appropriate discussions of past mistakes can originate.

The same cannot be said for most of the monuments this bill seeks to protect.

Honestly, answer this: What good can possibly come from naming schools after men who actively fought to prevent black people from receiving an education?

What benefit to society, or to the future of us living in this State together, do monuments that mention “white supremacy” serve?

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

We all know the answer. And we all know that the only reason some people want to keep those monuments is because they serve as a middle finger to black people.

But don’t fret, Gov. Ivey, you don’t have to get bogged down in the matter of human decency. Instead, you can use something that Republicans like yourself seem to understand – money.

This bill is going to cost Alabama millions upon millions – both in construction costs, lost project costs, delays and lawsuits.

As written, with every renovation, move, restoration, renaming or demolition of every building, structure, monument and street that meets the very broad definition of “historical” in this bill, we’ll have thousands of requests to the new nine-person review board.

You’ve already been forced to attach an amendment that excludes school projects, because more than $34 million in existing construction was set to be upended by this stupid bill.

You’re already getting pushback from the business community and the almighty BCA, which is concerned over how this bill will be viewed by relocating companies.

So, use the money excuse, put this abomination in your pocket and let’s save ourselves from at least one national embarrassment.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Yours truly,

Josh Moon


Josh Moon is an investigative reporter and featured columnist at the Alabama Political Reporter with years of political reporting experience in Alabama. You can email him at [email protected] or follow him on Twitter.

More from APR


Advocates argued that debt-based suspensions only created further harm.


The bill came about after students at Trinity Presbyterian School realized the state had no official state cookie.


Ivey has overseen a total increase of 15 percent during her time as governor.


Altogether, the state's budgets represent $15 billion in appropriations.