Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?


Senate forum held in Huntsville

By Brandon Moseley
Alabama Political Reporter

Wednesday, July 6, 2017, over half of the candidates for Senate were on hand for the Christian Citizen Task Force’s bipartisan US Senate forum at Huntsville’s Rock Worship Center. An enthusiastic crowd of over 350 were in attendance.

Afterwards there was a straw poll to gauge how the audience was planning to vote. Congressman Mo Brooks won the Republican straw poll, followed by former Chief Justice Roy Moore. Brian McGee won the Democratic straw poll, followed by Dr. Will Boyd.

The first candidate to speak was Dr. Will Boyd (D). Boyd said that he is the Chairman of the Lauderdale County Democratic Party and is the pastor of St. Mark’s Missionary Baptist Church in Florence. He is a former Greenville, Illinois city councilman and a former college administrator. Rev. Boyd said, “I believe in a strong economy. We need to do all we can to make sure Americans have good jobs.” Boyd said, “Everybody in our State needs access to affordable healthcare. 900,000 people in Alabama live in poverty. We have 1 million people with disabilities. Education is important. We spend twice as much housing a prisoner as educating a child. I am ready to go to work for you.”

Dr. Randy Brinson (R) said, “I came to Alabama to serve as a physician in the Air Force. After my times serving at Maxwell Air Force Base in Montgomery, we decided to stay.”  Brinson said that after he took a stand defending: a child’s right to pray in Jesus’s name, say prayers at baseball games, and standing up for home schoolers he got the attention of the national Christian Coalition. “12 years ago I was named as President of the Alabama Christian Coalition.” Working with the legislature, I realized then that fighting corruption was the most important issue facing Alabama. In recent months we have had the heads of every Branch of Government in Alabama removed. Two weeks ago a legislator in Birmingham (Rep. Oliver Robinson) pleaded guilty for bribery and corruption in a scandal that involved Drummond Coal. Three months ago Governor Bentley (R) had to resign. I have called Luther Strange: Mr. corruption. I am not backing down from that.” Brinson said, “Jesus Christ is my personal savior. I will stand up and fight for you in the Senate. Lets send Alabama to Washington, no Washington to Alabama.”

US Representative Mo Brooks (R-Huntsville) said, “I have carried the banner of the Republican Party 12 times.”  My wife Martha and I have been married for 41 years we have four children. They all live in Alabama. Paul Sanford and Phil Williams have both endorsed me in a Republican Primary which is rare for an office holder. Brooks said that there is an ethical cloud over the appointment process so much so that Kay Ivey moved the Special Election up from 2018. I have a 30 year spotless record. This is a record for US Senator which is arguably the 3rd or 4th most powerful elected leader in the country. This is not a city council or county commission race. I have a proven conservative record.

Vann Caldwell (D) said, I am the constable from Talladega County. I have a Political Science Degree in University of Alabama with an emphasis on history. My main objectives will be to improve economic growth and homeland security.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Mary Maxwell (R) said, “Thank you for letting me speak in your beautiful Alabama. It is now my Alabama.  I would like you to pick me because I know what I am doing. I know right from wrong.”  “Send me to Washington and watch the newspapers because there will be a blow up.”  Maxwell said that the Constitution does not allow the US to go to war without a declaration of war from the Congress. The Constitution does not evolve by violating it.” Maxwell warned that people are suggesting that we go to war with North Korea or Iran because they have some new weapons. “99 members of the Senate don’t care. Rand Paul is different. If they did care they would not allow it. I have written 12 books many of them on law where I am a researcher.”

Brian McGee (D) said, I am a former Army officer who fought in Vietnam and I am a career teacher. “Put a career educator in the United States Senate.”  I wasn’t born here. I was born in the Panama Canal Zone. I was an Army brat who moved from state to state with my dad. I was raised Catholic and attended both public and Catholic schools. I attend St Mary’s Church in Opelika. I have been married to my wife for 47 years. Four generations of McGees have served in the US Army during wars: World War I, World War II, Vietnam, and the Persian Gulf. There are serious questions how Luther Strange got appointed and why he was trying to block an EPA Superfund site in Birmingham. “I will put people above party and people above money.”

Former Chief Justice Roy Moore (R) said, I am here with my wife, Kayla. I come from a farming background. I went to West Point and Vietnam. I became a lawyer. A judge eventually Chief Justice. “In November we were given a second chance.”  We need to make America strong. I want to make our military stronger. I agree with military leaders on curtailing transgender rights in the military. It will kill the military. I am for getting rid of the IRS. I favor the fair tax, the flat tax, or something like that. Judges do not make law. I want to go to the Senate and scrutinize these judge nominees. “To make America great we need to make America good. To make America good we need to make God great again in America.”

Bryan Peeples (R) said, “It is about people, it is not about me.”  I recently met a Mother of a 19 year old Autistic child and she can’t get her son any more Autistic therapy because it is not covered by Medicaid. This is about her. It is about disabled veterans going to the VA and told they are going to have to wait months for care. We are all Americans and that is what this election is about. “We have a generation that needs to step up and lead and not follow anymore. All of you need to be heard. My voice is not important, yours is. As your senator I will proudly serve your voice.”

State Senator Trip Pittman (R-Montrose) said, “I am here because Jesus Christ is my Lord and I am following his will.”  I was in a plane crash then I ran for elected office. Before we put our men on the ground in a war zone we do need to declare war. If we have declared war in Korea we would likely not be facing that situation today.  In the state Senate I have been budget chairman.  I and my colleagues passed the toughest immigration law in the land; but had it thrown out by the courts. We passed laws to require drug testing for welfare beneficiaries. Pittman said that the free enterprise system gives us the best opportunity to be successful. Government should be limited. Socialism is on the ash heap of history. I have my business experience, experience in the military and have experience as a legislator.  President John Adams said, “Our Constitution was made only for a moral and religious people. It is wholly inadequate to the government of any other.”

After introductions, audience members stood in line to ask the candidates questions.

The first audience member asked about how often they would hold town halls if elected.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Dr. Will Boyd (D) answered “I plan to have forums wherever possible at least once per quarter, and they would be all over the State.”

Dr. Randy Brinson (R) said that communicating with the people is very important. “I am the only job creator on record. We are building homes in Florence to go overseas generating $millions for the economy.”

Rep. Mo Brooks (R) said Traditionally I have held lots of town halls, but that recently out of town protesters have been crowding the town halls and threatening the Congress members and the citizens attending. I have met with every constituent group who has asked to meet with me. There has to be proper communication and proper security. I will try to do the best I can do for all 67 counties.

Constable Vann Caldwell (D) said he would have a minimum of two town halls yearly and a maximum of times yearly.

Mary Maxwell (R) condemned Professional provocateurs. “I am planning to appoint a committee of ten volunteers to enhance the flow of communication.” Maxwell said that there were not many young people in the audience. We have to find the young people. Millennials we have to find them and tell them that they have every right to participate and more so because they will have to live with what happens longer than we will.”

Brian McGee (D) lashed out at Brooks saying that when the Tea Party came to the town halls he wasn’t complaining. McGee said that he went to Birmingham and asked to see both Senators Strange and Shelby. They refused to see me. Their staffs took my phone numbers and said they would give me a call. Did I get a call? No.”

Judge Moore (R) said, “My door has always been open and I have gone out and spoken all over the State.”

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Peeples (R) said that with today’s modern technology we can engage whenever possible. “I will be in the district whenever the Senate is in recess. I will be on Facebook live and Instagram. We are here to serve you and not to serve any agenda. I will personally respond to each and every one of you.”

Sen. Pittman (R) said, “I make my living selling tractors to farmers and equipment to contractors,” so I know how to communicate. What is important is we need a resurgence in faith and family. I have strong philosophical underpinnings thus feel comfortable standing up and explaining myself. “The free enterprise system gives us the ability to help people.”

Rep. Mo Brooks defended his record in the Congress when pressed by a hostile constituent. “I have been able to change statutory language over 60 different times and I have been a conservative leader.” The Heritage Foundation ranked me in the top ten members of Congress. On border security I was ranked number one over the last six years. If you look at my re-election record I have won thirty point margins of victories. That show s that I represents the wishes of the people.

A member of the audience asked each of them: If they could only accomplish one thing in the Senate what would they want it to be?

Dr. Boyd said, “My student success and empowerment bill. When education is instituted it changes the dynamic.”

Dr. Brinson said, “Repeal and replace Obamacare. I am the only person on the panel with a plan to repeal and replace Obamacare.”

Congressman Brooks said, “If we don’t change the rules of the Senate the conservative agenda is dead in the United States Senate. My number one goal is to change the rules of the Senate so that a 52 seat majority is not held hostage to a 48 seat minority.” The people voted for Republicans to control the Senate, for Republicans to control the House of Representatives, and for a Republican President. “The will of the people is being thwarted by Democrats and their liberal agenda.”

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Rep. Brooks said “The incumbent (Luther Strange) has signed a letter saying that he wants us to keep those rules in place.”

Constable Caldwell said that “As a business owner I want to restore the American dream. I will protect the Constitution. Economic growth is the main thing. I will defend your rights.”

Maxwell answered, “Investigate the cause of the Autism epidemic where one out of 68 boys are autistic.” Maxwell suggested that the MMR vaccine causes Autism.

McGee responded, “We have got to get money out of politics. Citizens United was the worst thing that the Supreme Court has ever done.” Medicaid needs to be fixed. We should also be fixing the Affordable Care Act, not repealing it.

Judge Moore said that “There is a great misunderstanding of the Constitution. I would like to end the differences that divide us; White and Black, rich and poor.”

Peeples responding to Brinson’s comment about him being the only one with a plan to repeal Obamacare said, “I have a four point comprehensive health care plan that repeals Obamacare and four separate pieces of Legislation to replace it.”  “I can’t do this alone. I promise to work with people across the aisle instead of going it alone like we have done for the last 20 years.”

Sen. Pittman answered, I believe in term limits. We need to have an honest debate and understand what works and what doesn’t. It is critical that you lead by example. I will work to continue the greatness that has always been here.”

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

An admitted former drug addict asked the candidates what they would do about the opioid epidemic.

Dr. Boyd said, “I am on the board of directors of the Board of health in Lauderdale County and also in Florence. We do have a problem and we need programs to eradicate opioid addiction.”

Dr. Brinson said, “We have an opioid crisis in Alabama. We have the highest rate of opioid use in the nation. Kentucky is a distant second. We need to clamp down on doctors that make it too easy to get. We need to improve addiction treatment in this State and we need comprehensive mental healthcare.”

Rep. Brooks said, “I am a firm believer in the 10th amendment. Let the states work their way through the problem. Families have a responsibility, church has a responsibility, friends and the community have a responsibility, we all have a role but it can’t be a government alone solution.”

Caldwell said, We have the highest rate of incarceration in the world. If someone gets sick we don’t put them in jail.”

Maxwell suggested that a doctor has invented a cure to opioid dependency, but that the government is suppressing the information.

McGee said, “We should look at the cause of the problem and that is a lack of hope. We should not be putting people in jail again. We need to solve these problems and not keep treating the symptoms.”…”and we need to raise the minimum wage.”

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Judge Moore answered, “Of course we have a drug problem. We need to teach people hope. How do you do that? You teach them about God.  Also stop drugs crossing the border and coming up from South America.”

Peeples said. “It is a crisis. Rush Limbaugh had an addiction to opioids that he was getting on the black market. We need to look at alternative solutions to pain management. We need to deal with this not on a State level, but on a National level.”

Sen. Pittman said that he was prescribed a lot of opioids after his plane crash, “Most of them are still in my medicine cabinet. I still have pain and I take an Alleve a day. We need a resurgence in responsibility and a resurgence in work ethic because that is what gives you confidence.”

Pittman lashed out at Luther Strange: “I would appreciate it if some of the people currently in office would come out and defend their views in forums like this. If you can’t come out and talk to the people in a campaign you won’t come out when in office……he is already in office.”

A veteran asked the candidates what they would do to improve the Veterans Health Care System.

Dr. Brinson said that he has worked in the VA system and that meeting veterans’ healthcare needs would be one of his priorities. “If the VA can’t see them in 2 weeks they should be able to go to a private doctor.”

Rep. Brooks said that he favors giving every veteran a gold plated card giving them the option to get their care from any doctor or hospital.  Brooks said that competition would force the VA to compete as they are losing their customer based to the private sector.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Maxwell said, “167,000 veterans are on disability because of either Gulf War Syndrome or the Anthrax vaccine which was experimental.” Maxwell accused the government of experimenting on veterans and suggested that people be put on trial for treason.

McGee said that he is a disabled veteran himself, “Just a ten percent disability.”  One out of ten adults in Alabama are veterans. “Privatization is not the answer. It would only take more money out of the system. We need to fix the VA. The VA needs more funding.

Judge Moore said, “The same people that want the government to take over healthcare can’t run a VA healthcare system. Government can’t do it well. We do owe it to our veterans they have served us and we should take care of them.”

Peeples said that he favored removing the lifetime benefits of Congress and give that back to our veterans.

Sen. Pittman said that the men and women who put their lives on the line for thos country deserve better care than what they are getting. “We do need more funding.” Pittman pointed out that the VA system is a single payer healthcare system and the government does not manage it very well.

On the Republican side: Mo Brooks had 101 votes, Roy Moore had 74, Trip Pittman eight, Randy Brinson six, Bryan Peeples five, Mary Maxwell three, and Luther Strange had three votes.

On the Democratic side: Brian McGee had nineteen votes, Will Boyd had twelve, Doug Jones had five, Michael Hansen two, Vann Caldwell one, and Jason Fisher one.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

The Major Party Primaries are on August 15 and the Special General Election is on December 12.


Brandon Moseley is a former reporter at the Alabama Political Reporter.

More from APR


This change would fundamentally undermine the Ethics Commission's independence, compromising its ability to function.


A group of 30 Republican sheriffs and police chiefs came out to support her effort to be the next chief justice.


241 bills were introduced during the first week of the 2024 Legislative Session. 


The State Government Affairs Committee approved the bill, sponsored by Sen. Garlan Gudger, R-Cullman.