Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Featured Opinion

The Montgomery schools con game


By Josh Moon
Alabama Political Reporter

There’s a con taking place in Montgomery.

OK, maybe I should be more specific, since cons aren’t exactly rare in this town.

Ed Richardson and the Alabama State Department of Education are conning you. The interim state schools superintendent has you watching the exploding card trick over there as he takes your watch over here.

Actually, it’s worse: He’s taking classroom teachers and school buildings over here — from a school district that is struggling and barely surviving and watching kids fall through the cracks every single day.

He’s taking the only lifeline they’ve got. A hundred lifelines.


Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Because Richardson — at the encouragement of city officials and other influential people around Montgomery — has decided that a state law requiring that school systems maintain one month’s reserves in savings is more important than those teachers and those drowning kids.

It is a law numerous other systems are currently violating.

It is a law that has never been enforced, because how in the world would you enforce it?

But suddenly, in Montgomery — and ONLY IN MONTGOMERY — this state law has become of utmost importance. More important than children learning. More important than teachers losing their jobs. More important than a school system failing.

MPS must have $19 million in reserves. It only has $11 million.

So, let’s burn it to the ground.

Look, I get it, reserves are important. For example, let’s say you’re in a situation where your system is drastically underfunded and you’re in desperate need of educating children the best way you can.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

In such a situation, you might have to dip into your emergency reserve fund.

Which, of course, is exactly what MPS officials have been doing for the better part of the last decade.

They are the lowest funded school system in the state — and the state funds its schools at one of the lowest rates in the nation — and are overrun with deteriorating buildings and understaffing. School systems in much, much better shape — both from a funding standpoint and a facilities standpoint — are routinely missing the one-month reserve rule.

And yet, not a peep from Richardson and ALSDE.

But then, this isn’t really about having one month’s reserves on hand.

It’s about charter schools. And about outsourcing. And about figuring out ways to divert public tax dollars into the pockets of private business owners. And it’s about getting white people to move into Montgomery, because the city is so heavily in debt that its only hope of avoiding serious financial meltdown in the future is to up the tax base.

We have been playing this con game for a long time here — the white people pretending that there’s a problem within MPS that is different from the obvious problem.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

They have blamed it on everything under the sun, and they’ve usually settled on vilifying the county school board. The board, which is elected by the people of the county, has been the problem for 20-plus years.

Not the extreme poverty. Not the racist funding structure. Not the legislature siphoning tax dollars to pay for private schools. Not white people fleeing to Pike Road and then immediately paying three times the tax rate to fund their schools. Not the idiotic decision to suck 30 percent of your best students out of every school and congregate them in magnet schools.

Spare me the con game. I know how this ends, because I’ve been here watching this charade for a long time.

City and county leaders, like state lawmakers, have been dancing around the primary issues for years, trying desperately to come up with some way to avoid addressing a history of awfulness that has come home to roost. They know the real problems, but correcting them will take too long, and they’re so overextended financially — mostly from financing their previous quick-fixes — that they can’t wait.

And so, here’s my prediction: Next year, after this massive cut and more talk about how lowly and pathetic MPS is (mostly because of the board, you know *wink*), there will be more cuts next year, thanks to the county commission pulling nearly $3 million. Those cuts will involve consolidating schools and booting poor ol’ janitors off the payroll in favor of outsourced contracts.

That’ll leave quite a few open school buildings that can be snapped up on the cheap by a new crop of charter schools, whose lobbyists and executives may or may not have been spending quite a bit of time in Montgomery lately.

None of this will do a damn thing to fix the education problems or crime problems or workforce readiness problems in this city. But it’ll allow the city to promote its new schools to would-be residents, promising yet another pathway for well-to-do kids to get a quality education while we pretend that the poverty-stricken kids will just vanish into thin air upon leaving school.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

That’s the way it’ll go. There’s likely nothing that can stop it.

Just don’t fall for the con along the way.  


EDIT: An earlier version of this column stated that MPS would be cutting 100-plus teachers from the district. That plan was rejected by Richardson, according to sources, and MPS officials are now awaiting his preference on a plan for raising the reserve cash, which will likely include heavy cuts at the MPS central office and school consolidation. He’s also asked the board to provide a clear plan for using money saved by staff cuts.


Josh Moon is an investigative reporter and featured columnist at the Alabama Political Reporter with years of political reporting experience in Alabama. You can email him at [email protected] or follow him on Twitter.

More from APR


The breached data potentially includes personally identifiable information such as names, addresses, and Social Security numbers.


The offense is a secondary violation, meaning a driver must be stopped for another reason.


There is rarely a shortage of compelling, interesting or downright weird stories to find around Alabama.


The report found that foster children with disabilities are placed in on-site schools that fail to provide adequate education.