Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?


Judge denies state’s motion to dismiss in case alleging discrimination against minor parties


A federal judge has denied the State of Alabama’s motion to dismiss a case brought forth by the Libertarian Party of Alabama (LPA), in which the LPA alleges discrimination against minor parties for access to the voter registration list. 

The LPA filed a lawsuit against Alabama Secretary of State John Merrill earlier this year, claiming that the state discriminates against minor parties like the LPA that try to gain statewide ballot access. Merrill’s office is charging the LPA about $34,000 for an electronic copy of a list of registered voters plus an additional $850 credit or debit card fee, while the Democratic and Republican parties are able to obtain the list for free. 

The party claims that the law allowing the Democratic and Republican parties to get the list for free while charging minor parties a prohibitively expensive amount for the same list is in violation of the Free Speech Clause of the First Amendment and the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment.  

Merrill filed a motion to dismiss the case in February, saying “the burden on the Libertarian Party of Alabama here is minimal and the State’s interests are sufficiently strong to justify the burden” and that the state law is “facially valid.”

Judge Emily C. Marks of the U.S. District Court, Alabama Middle District, determined on Wednesday that the LPA sufficiently stated their claim against Merrill and that the case can move forward in court. 

“We are very pleased to be able to move forward on this case,” said Laura Lane, chair of the LPA. “We hope this will lead to ballot access reform in Alabama, making it easier for minor parties to have their candidates on the ballot.” 

The LPA explains in the lawsuit that this list is important in that it allows a political party to know the number of votes in a location so that the party can prioritize its efforts to gain support and helps parties reach out to “politically like-minded voters.” 

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

A party can gain ballot access on the statewide ballot by either performance or petition. 

For performance, a party must gain 20 percent of the vote in a statewide race. To remain on the ballot, the party must repeatedly gain at least 20 percent of the vote to qualify for the next cycle. 

For the petition, parties are required to gather signatures equal at least 3 percent of voters who voted in the last election for governor and submit those signatures in a petition to the secretary of state. Having access to the list of registered voters is necessary to confirm the validity of the signatures on the petitions. 

This means the Libertarian Party would need 51,588 signatures to be listed on the statewide ballot in 2020. 

Under Alabama law, the LPA is not entitled to a free copy of the voter registration list because the party does not currently qualify for ballot access.


Jessa Reid Bolling is a reporter at the Alabama Political Reporter and graduate of The University of Alabama with a B.A. in journalism and political science.

More from APR


The court filing argues that the board’s replacement of the challenged policy renders the suit moot.


Judge Maze acknowledged that plaintiffs had articulated valid constitutional theories for relief.


Homolak has brought her fight against LGBTQ representation in libraries to Alabama, particularly in the Huntsville area.


This is the first publicly known action from an Alabama university responding to the state's new anti-DEI law.