Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Featured Opinion

Opinion | The water is poison and there’s no one we trust to fix it

Toxic or contaminated water concept. Water tap on blur background with skull. 3d illustration

There’s too much lead in the water in Lauderdale County. 

The Alabama Department of Environmental Management issued that alert on Thursday, and if ADEM issued an alert, after all of the pollution they’ve kept quiet about, you can bet No. 2 pencils must be falling from the taps. 

ADEM has recommended a number of steps until the issues can be resolved, including using cold water for cooking, running the tap for several seconds before using the water and just buying bottled or using filtered water. 

They’ll let everyone know when the problem is resolved. 

And there’s the question, isn’t it? 

Do you trust ADEM? Do you really trust anyone in Alabama’s government to tell you the truth about this type of situation? Do you really trust them? Really? 

Because I seem to recall another water pollution situation that occurred in Lawrence and Morgan counties a few years ago. Testing showed high levels of other contaminants, and the head of a water authority told his customers to stop consuming that water. It was unsafe, he said, and he couldn’t bear the thought of not speaking up and a person being sickened by that water. 

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

But that didn’t stop Robert Bentley, then the governor of the state, from contradicting him. From hundreds of miles away. Having never consumed a drop of that water. 

Bentley called it a “crisis that doesn’t exist.” 

You’ll be shocked to learn that ol’ Doc Feelgood was emphatically wrong. The water was unsafe, and 3M agreed to pay the WMEL water board more than $30 million to clean up their mess. Last week, that water board purchased a new filtration system with that money. 

So, do you trust them? 

Because keep in mind, this is the same ADEM that is operated by people who were exposed for being way too cozy with industrial polluters during a public corruption trial in Birmingham a couple of years ago. 

This is the same ADEM that has handed out slaps on the wrist to repeat polluters, and then kept massive spills and incidents silent. 

This is the same ADEM that is often months behind volunteer organizations working for free in discovering pollution. To the point that it almost seems like they’re not really trying to find the pollution at times. 

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

So, do you trust them?

This is the same Alabama government, by the way, that has always, always sided with big business over environmental protections. And it has almost always found a way to justify taking funds that should go to environmental causes and diverting them to “economic development” projects and other nonsensical ideas. 

Like, say, taking funds from an oil spill settlement — funds that could have been used to secure Alabama marshlands and protective coast barriers for centuries — and using them to build a beachfront hotel. 

That act was egregious that a federal judge initially blocked it, because the hotel construction was clearly outside of the intended use of the funds. The state was forced to agree to a financially support a number of environmental causes, including dune restoration, before the suit was finally settled. 

So, again, do you trust them? 

Of course you don’t. And really, that’s a terrible thing to admit, isn’t it? That there’s no one to turn to on these matters. That there’s no one who has our back. That there’s not one single watchdog in our entire government who is willing to take up these causes and simply protect the people from obvious danger. 

I mean, feel free to correct me if I’m wrong on this. But I’m not. 

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

We literally caught the leadership of ADEM and other state environmental regulators cozying up to guilty polluters — helping them beat federal fines — and we did nothing. Those people are still in charge, and they’re still terrible at their jobs. 

And the governor, the person who controls whether all of them have jobs, is still waiting to see how this all plays out. 

That’s our reality. 

The water and the air and the dirt are all poisoned, and there’s no one we trust to find it, fix it or tell us it’s OK.


Josh Moon is an investigative reporter and featured columnist at the Alabama Political Reporter with years of political reporting experience in Alabama. You can email him at [email protected] or follow him on Twitter.

More from APR


The Selma Landing has recently been inoperable.


In 2022, Alabama began funding a large-scale project to update and improve every county's drinking water and sewer needs.


A 12-member jury of Trump's peers in New York found him guilty of falsifying business records.


Alabama's proposed permit plan did not meet federal regulations for managing coal ash landfills and impoundments.