Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Featured Opinion

Opinion | Ignore the attacks. The AEA is public education’s only hope in Alabama

“With AEA’s influence growing again, the right-wing attacks have started. Because it’s the only hope to protect public education.”


You had to know that the attacks on the Alabama Education Association were coming. They were as easy to predict as 90-degree temps in an Alabama August. Right about the time the state Legislature, led by Republicans, voted to delay implementation of a component of the Literacy Act that would retain third-graders who failed to meet reading standards. 

The Literacy Act was an important bill in political circles, because it allowed the state to manipulate Alabama’s pathetically low national reading rankings while barely lifting a finger to do so. (Oh, ALGOP apologists will tell you that it’s all about the kids and their ability to read, but ask yourself one question: Why were they held back only in the third grade? It probably has nothing to do with the Nation’s Report Card testing fourth-graders, right?)

Anyway, when a bill to delay that component of the Literacy Act was pushed through the legislature — and particularly when Republicans cut off debate by other Republicans over the delay — quite a few people took notice that the AEA, once the most dominant force in Alabama politics, was back in the game. 

So, the attacks from the far-right, anti-public education section of ALGOP were inevitable. And predictably ignorant. 

The latest was a column published Monday by’s Dana Hall McCain insisting that AEA doesn’t represent conservative teachers. Her “proof”: this one time the National Education Association voted to provide teachers with educational materials and accurate information concerning Critical Race Theory. 

That’s it. 

If you’re unfamiliar with Critical Race Theory, it’s a 40-year-old academic concept that explores race as a social construct that’s embedded within America’s legal system and government policies. It isn’t taught for a single second in any K-12 classroom, and its presence at an NEA conference was merely about the national organization supporting the theory and pledging to provide teachers with accurate and already available information. And, oh yeah, no one from AEA voted for or had anything to do with the proposal. 

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

But none of that matters. It was time to attack the AEA, so out came the boogeymen. 

And McCain pulled out all the stops — CRT, her Black friends, even the bible. That’s right, it’s apparently anti-Christian to point out that America has failed repeatedly to live up to God’s command to do nothing out of selfish ambition. (And that’s to say nothing of the commandment to love one another.)

Honestly, this entire CRT “controversy” is so absurd. And nothing more than a bunch of white people worried they’ll learn something and no longer be able to lean on tired stereotypes and easy racism. 

But to McCain’s larger point — that AEA doesn’t represent conservative teachers — she writes that many in her family are conservative teachers and they’ve had a hard time since the late Paul Hubbert retired and the organization somehow shifted left. 

Except, small problem, it hasn’t. 

The AEA is doing today what it’s always done: protect public education and public education employees. 

What has changed is the hyper-partisan atmosphere which has divided all of America, Alabama included, into political teams, where voters no longer vote for their own interests and benefits but instead get wrapped up in this silly political game. 

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

In the days of Hubbert, that wasn’t the case. Very few people were concerned with the “liberal” or “conservative” labels. They wanted candidates who would support public education and a teachers union that would protect them, their jobs and their benefits. 

That’s what they got then. And that’s still what they have today. 

That’s a problem for Republicans, since they’ve spent the last decade-plus courting candidates who have done everything imaginable to undercut public education in this state. 

Once in office, those anti-public education politicians have spent the last 11 years vilifying teachers — calling them lazy and leeches — and cutting their pay and benefits — to the point that we’re just now achieving 2008 funding levels — and propping up charter schools and private schools and any hairbrained endeavor that allowed private business to get their grubby fingers on public education dollars.

That’s why AEA’s membership is growing and the organization’s influence is once again being felt. 

Because in real life, teachers got tired of being kicked repeatedly. Got tired of being told that their tenure was the problem — and not the fact that they were being asked to buy their own classroom supplies and toilet paper. Got tired of hearing about how wonderful all those under-performing charter schools were. Got tired of hearing about how they’re failing in impossible situations from the very people who created those impossible situations. 

Alabama’s public school employees have taken a hard look at the last 11 years of education life in this state, and they don’t like what they see. The state’s largest voting bloc is motivated and angry. 

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

The only recourse for anti-public education Republicans is to attack the AEA. Don’t buy it.

Josh Moon is an investigative reporter and featured columnist at the Alabama Political Reporter with years of political reporting experience in Alabama. You can email him at [email protected] or follow him on Twitter.

More from APR


The language is similar to Alabama's language prohibiting divisive concepts.


It's still unclear—even to board member John Wahl—who decides what material is inappropriate for minors.


Athens Police said neither victim nor witness implied any political motivation.


The bill would provide an avenue for librarians to be arrested if someone challenges a book as being "harmful to minors."