Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?


Will “Aniah’s Law” affect due process? Some opponents say yes

The amendment has gained support on both sides of the aisle, but has also drawn criticism from both parties.


The Legislature unanimously approved putting “Aniah’s Law” on the ballot this election and officials on both sides of the aisle have urged its passing.

But there is also a bipartisan opposition that has arisen to the amendment, which would allow judges to deny bail to people charged with 13 felony offenses.

Tabitha Isner, vice chair of the Alabama Democratic Party, said it’s the unintended consequences of the amendment that make it a bad choice for Alabama.

“The intended consequences of this law are wonderful,” Isner said. “The unintended consequences of this law haven’t been talked about and are much larger than people realize.”

The law is a response to the kidnapping and murder of 19-year-old Aniah Blanchard in Auburn in 2019. Her accused killer was out on bond for another violent felony offense.

The presumption, Isner said, is that this bill would prevent such a tragedy in the future.

“Any time a law is described as something that would have prevented a tragic death, a terrible murder, of course we all want to vote for something that would prevent terrible violence that would save a life,” Isner said. “That’s why folks support this because it’s being framed as a law that would have saved Aniah’s life. What’s unfortunate about that is we don’t know this law would have saved Aniah’s life, and we can’t promise it would save additional lives. Even if it does, it can also ruin many many lives.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

“If you imagine it’s your daughter that’s going to be saved from murder, this seems like a great idea. If you imagine it’s your son going to be accused of burglary and locked up for 10 years while innocent it’s a terrible law and we have to consider both of those scenarios when we make legislation.”

Jefferson County judge David Carpenter chimed in with his support in response to a tweet by Isner on Wednesday.

“Giving the government the authority to hold you indefinitely before trial is a bad idea,” Carpenter said in the tweet. “It is a power that will be abused. A lot. And that’s coming from someone who will have that power.”

The Southern Poverty Law Center has also taken a stand against the amendment for its impact on due process.

“With the backlog we see in our courts, that will be further exacerbated,” Jerome Dees, policy director for the SPLC in Alabama, told “We could have individuals stuck in jail for years at a time and ultimately not found guilty. They are innocent the day they are charged but still could be in jail for months and years.”

The Alabama Policy Institute raised similar concerns about the amendment in a release this week, although the Conservative think tank did not specifically recommend voting no on the amendment.

“While the sentiment for ratifying the law is understandable, it does raise due process concerns for those accused, but not yet convicted, of crimes,” API said in its breakdown of the amendment.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Other groups, such as the Alabama League of Women Voters, have grappled with the amendment and decided to take no official position.

“There was a lot of debate within our own board, and a lot of emotion,” said LWV president Kathy Jones. “This is in response to a brutal murder; it was a real tragedy. We basically balance that against setting up new ways for people to not have bail before pre-detention hearings. We didn’t feel comfortable making a position on it.”

Gov. Kay Ivey recently urged voters to support the bill, as did the mayors of Alabama’s 10 biggest cities.

The voters will decide the fate of the amendment at the polls on Tuesday, November 8.

Jacob Holmes is a reporter at the Alabama Political Reporter. You can reach him at [email protected]

More from APR


A mix of polling and "push polling" yields results that are at best questionable, and at worst, significantly misleading.


The right-wing think tank set 30 policy priorities, including removing barriers to have 14- and 15-year-olds join the labor force.


The Alabama Policy Institute disassociates from 1819 News following Mayor Copeland's suicide, amidst scrutiny over their historical and financial connections.

Party politics

A vote must be held on new bylaws by Feb. 1, 2024, the DNC committee ruled.