Republican elephant and Democratic donkey symbols loom above the Alabama Capitol in a composite illustration.
Adobe stock / APR graphic

Opinion How political revolutions begin in Alabama

Republicans kept their supermajorities, but Madison County showed the cracks have already reached home.

Power that no longer has to compete for votes can forget whom it serves. Alabama’s election carried a warning about that danger, and a reminder of what public service requires.

“We hear you loud and clear,” Alabama House Speaker Nathaniel Ledbetter wrote after the election. He named the rising cost of living, education, infrastructure, access to health care and jobs. He credited Republican candidates, their records and their fundraising for the party’s success. He described the Republican supermajority as “alive and well” and added, “We intend to wield it to deliver on the priorities you care about most.”

Ledbetter is an honorable man, and there is every reason to believe he heard the voters. When he took the speaker’s gavel in 2023, he said it should be a tool to ensure open debate, not a weapon to stifle it. That is the right standard. The question is how many members of his caucus will hold themselves to it—and how many will take another supermajority as permission to carry on as before.

In 88 of Alabama’s 140 legislative races, only one candidate appeared on the general election ballot. A lawmaker can come through an election like that feeling pretty good about how things are going. The voters who had no alternative may have a different view.

The rest of the ballot gives those lawmakers a place to look. As APR reported, nearly 550,000 Alabamians voted a straight Democratic ticket, up 84 percent from four years ago. Republican straight-ticket votes slipped slightly to about 645,000. Democrats gained ground on that measure in all 67 counties.

A quarter of a million more Alabamians chose the Democratic ticket, and Alabama Democrats fielded candidates in just 73 legislative races. How many of those voters would have backed a Democrat for the Legislature if they’d had one to vote for?

The South’s red wall is cracking all around Alabama. Mississippi elected Scott Colom, the first Democrat elected to the U.S. Senate from that state since 1982. Georgia reelected Jon Ossoff and handed Democrats every statewide office on the ballot, including the governor’s mansion. Florida Republicans lost their supermajorities in both legislative chambers, and Tennessee Democrats flipped six Republican-held state House seats.

North Carolina offers an especially direct lesson. Republicans took both chambers there in 2010, the same year Republicans took the Alabama State House. This year, North Carolina Democrats put candidates on the ballot in 164 of 170 legislative races. They won the House and ended the Republican supermajority in the Senate.

Alabama Republicans knew what to do in 2010. They went out and found people willing to run in places Democrats had governed for years. Voters who wanted a change had somebody to vote for. Sixteen years later, Republicans are the ones who have to answer for the decisions they’ve made at the State House.

In the Madison County area, Democrats took two Senate seats and a House seat Republicans had held. Republican Senator Sam Givhan outspent Democrat Jared Sluss more than 21 to 1. Sluss won by 577 votes.

State Senator Chris Elliott, a Republican from Josephine, took the losses and close calls seriously. On “The Jeff Poor Show,” he asked about the difference in turnout and whether voters were dissatisfied with Republicans, the top of the ticket, the president or “our policies.” Then he got specific. “There are voters who want us to pay attention to pocketbook issues that they feel we’ve not done a good enough job with.”

Elliott pointed to the victory of Allison Montgomery, a transgender woman elected to represent House District 25, as evidence that Republicans needed to reckon with voter frustration.

There is a deeper question for his party. What happens when politicians spend so much time telling voters whom to fear that they lose sight of the people they are supposed to serve?

Last year, Alabama Republicans passed a bill they called the “What is a Woman Act.” In October, Alabama Republican Party Chairman Scott Stadthagen called Montgomery and Terri Osborne, a transgender candidate in Baldwin County, mentally ill. Voters in House District 25 elected Montgomery anyway. She ran on the issues facing her district. After she won, she made a promise.

“I’m going to work especially hard for those who hate me, because they deserve a better Alabama as much as anyone.”

Somebody in her district may never vote for Allison Montgomery. One day he may need her help. She’s already told him what he can expect from her.

Madison County also elected Brett Jones, an openly gay former Navy SEAL, as sheriff. On June 10, 1993, conservative icon Barry Goldwater, the 1964 Republican presidential nominee, argued for allowing gay Americans to serve openly in the military.

“You don’t need to be ‘straight’ to fight and die for your country,” he wrote in The Washington Post. “You just need to shoot straight.”

Thirty-three years later, Madison County voters chose Jones to do a job. Voters in House District 25 chose Montgomery to do another. Both will have to answer for how well they serve.

Alabama’s Constitution settles the question of whom that service is owed to. Its Declaration of Rights begins by declaring that all men are equally free and independent. The next section says all political power is inherent in the people and that free governments are instituted for their benefit. It does not say for the benefit of a party, a caucus or the voters who backed the winner. It says the people. The Fourteenth Amendment makes the obligation of equal protection explicit. No state may deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws. Any person.

Before taking up their duties, every member of the Legislature swears to support the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of Alabama and to discharge the duties of the office “faithfully and honestly.” The oath does not exempt the constituents who voted for someone else.

Republicans have principles that point the same way. Individual liberty. Personal responsibility. Government held accountable to the people. Goldwater understood that conservative principles had consequences for how government treated gay Americans.

A party loses its way when it encourages voters to question whether their neighbors deserve the same dignity and respect they expect for themselves. After years of portraying those neighbors as threats, it should ask what voters saw in them as candidates.

The danger of one-party power is not only what it does to its opponents. It is what it does to itself. A lawmaker who goes years without an opponent can go years hearing mostly from allies. That is how a government can drift from the people it serves without anyone deciding it should. When power faces no questions at the ballot box, it needs more of them everywhere else.

Political revolutions begin when somebody runs in a place where the outcome is supposed to be settled and enough people decide they’d like a say in it. Alabama Democrats have work to do before 2030. It starts with recruiting candidates who know their communities, giving voters a meaningful choice and returning after a loss.

Republicans have work to do sooner. When the Legislature convenes, will they give a good bill a hearing when it comes from a Democrat? Will they ask hard questions about how the state spends the public’s money when the people responsible are members of their own party? When a town is struggling to keep its hospital open, will lawmakers give it the same attention whether its representative is a Republican or a Democrat?

Citizens have work to do, too. If your lawmaker had no opponent in November, call the office anyway. Show up at the town hall. Read the voting record. Ask what was done with your money. And if no one in your district will run in 2030, ask whether that someone might be you.

Ledbetter has said Republicans will use their power to deliver on the priorities Alabamians care about. His colleagues should take that commitment seriously. Those who had no opponent in November have as much to learn from this election as those who nearly lost. And every one of them owes the same duty to the people who voted against them as to the people who put them in office.