Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Featured Opinion

The Alabama Ethics Commission is failing us

By Josh Moon
Alabama Political Reporter

The Alabama Ethics Commission has become a joke.

Let’s all stop pretending that this five-man panel, along with its Executive Director and legal counsel, are any sort of a defense against corrupt public servants or a means to punish public corruption.

They’re not.

Not consistently.

And not without an air of corruption and good-ol’-boy backroom dealing surrounding nearly everything they do.

Need examples?

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Well, first off, read Bill and Susan Britt’s interview with outgoing commissioner Stewart Tankersley. Secondly, consider all of the problems this bunch has created when a simple, straightforward interpretation of law was all anyone expected.

Need some examples? Let’s go.

On Monday, Randy Brinson openly criticized the Commission for pushing its scheduled meeting from August 2 to August 16. That new date placed the meeting one day after the Republican primary in the special-called Senate election.

That’s a big deal, because the Commission was expected to take up a complaint filed by Alabama Secretary of State John Merrill against appointed Sen. Luther Strange, who is running for the position. Merrill, as he told APR in May, believes Strange has violated two campaign finance laws – the same two violated by Gov. Robert Bentley, who ended up pleading guilty and resigning from office – and he wants the Commission to review.

And you’d think that if the guy who is in charge of monitoring campaign finance issues – the same guy who leveled similar charges against a Governor who resigned over those charges – filed allegations against Strange, the Ethics Commission, if only in the interest of sparing the state another national embarrassment, would move quickly to investigate his allegations.

But not our Ethics Commission.

It punted.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Actually, I take that back. Wrong football analogy, because that one implies that the Commission sent the problem to another entity that might solve it.

Allow me to restate: The Ethics Commission took a knee.

So, as Brinson said Monday, it’s likely – and in this State, that means probable – that we could have a runoff in which one of the candidates is deemed by the Ethics Commission to be a possible felon.


But that’s par for this Commission’s course.

Let’s not forget the utter debacle over the smear campaign against Jefferson County superintendent Craig Pouncey – a smear campaign the Commission foolishly allowed itself to be sucked into.

Let’s also not forget the “Friends of McCalla” farce, which only allowed the commissioners to continue to be lobbied.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Let’s also not forget that time Commissioner Charles Price – a member of the Montgomery Chamber of Commerce’s board and its upcoming president – voted on an action concerning the city’s funding of the Chamber, and when called on it Price said that the Ethics Commission isn’t beholden to the ethics laws it enforces. (No, for real, that’s true.)

Let’s also not forget the numerous times the Commission issued cover-their-butts opinions on behalf of lawmakers who were only looking to use their offices for personal gain.

Let’s also not forget the numerous examples of shady lobbying and questionable relationships between commissioners and subjects – relationships that have served to forever taint the Commission.

The idea of the Alabama Ethics Commission is a good one – a public body that serves as an ethics watchdog for the people of the state. The execution of that idea – a body that has been politicized and compromised to the point that no one believes in the purity of its opinions or actions – has fallen well short of that ideal.

And that’s no good to any of us.


Josh Moon is an investigative reporter and featured columnist at the Alabama Political Reporter with years of political reporting experience in Alabama. You can email him at [email protected] or follow him on Twitter.

More from the Alabama Political Reporter


Four years seems a long way off, but the 2026 governor’s race has already begun.

Featured Opinion

Alabama's capital city is a case study in how decades of racism and conservative public policy have led to gang problems.


There is rarely a shortage of compelling, interesting or downright weird stories to find around Alabama.


Alabama rarely fails to deliver when it comes to political news. 2022 was no exception.


ERIC is a multi-state voter information center that cross-checks voter data to prevent inter-state fraud.


Merrill said his office does not maintain the polling place lists and that the law requires county officials to post those lists.


The program was created by the Alabama Legislature in 2015 and is designed to improve access to fresh food.


Secretary of State John Merrill projects a turnout between 45 and 50 percent, which could break a record in voter numbers but not percentage.