Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?


What’s taking so long with the Mike Hubbard appeal?

By Josh Moon
Alabama Political Reporter

On Oct. 5, 2016, former House Speaker Mike Hubbard, two months removed from being found guilty of 12 felonies, officially filed an appeal in his case with the Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals.

Thirteen days later, in a Baldwin County Circuit Court, Justin Shawn Miller went on trial for robbing the Courtyard Marriott Hotel in Gulf Shores. Like Hubbard, Miller was convicted, sentenced and subsequently filed an appeal in mid-March 2017.

The difference between the two: The Court of Criminal Appeals issued an opinion on Miller’s appeal in October.

Hubbard is still waiting. Still a free man. Still no closer to serving the four-year sentence handed down.

Why that is, no one seems capable of answering publicly. But privately, sources close to the Appeals Court judges told APR that the judges want to wait and see how the primary elections play out this June before issuing a ruling because they fear political backlash no matter which way they rule.

One thing is certain, however: It is becoming impossible, even in Alabama’s underfunded court system, to blame the delay in ruling on Hubbard’s case on a backlog.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Each announcement of opinions from the Court only highlights the obvious.

For example: the case of Patrick Edward Arnold, who was convicted of third-degree burglary in March 2017. Arnold filed his appeal with the Court in May, more than seven months after Hubbard’s was filed.

The Court issued an opinion in Arnold’s case on Dec. 15.

In that same list of opinions was a case remanded from the U.S. Supreme Court in May and another case appealed in May.

So, the Court has apparently moved on to May’s appeals, except for one.

The guy, convicted of 12 felonies for misusing his office for personal gain, is still waiting.


Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Josh Moon is an investigative reporter and featured columnist at the Alabama Political Reporter with years of political reporting experience in Alabama. You can email him at [email protected] or follow him on Twitter.

More from the Alabama Political Reporter


Court of Criminal Appeals Place 2 will be an open seat in the 2024 campaign after Judge Chris McCool announced a run for Supreme...


There is rarely a shortage of compelling, interesting or downright weird stories to find around Alabama.

Featured Opinion

A Wetumpka judge convicted two elderly women on four misdemeanor charges related to feeding stray cats.

Featured Opinion

If the election of Donald Trump taught us anything, it's this: Elections have lifetime consequences.


The plaintiffs say the state's "race-blind" approach to drawing maps is a strategy to disenfranchise Black voters.


Dothan's Letitia Jackson, a plaintiff in the case, said the case boils down to simply ensuring her vote counts as much as your vote


The former sheriff had asked the Court of Criminal Appeals to declare a mistrial after the AG's office hid an investigation of a witness.


Rep. Chris Pringle, R-Mobile, carried the redistricting legislation in the House last year.