Gov. Robert Bentley appointed Steve Marshall to be Alabama attorney general after Marshall agreed to launch an investigation into Special Prosecution Division Chief Matt Hart and Acting Attorney General Van Davis, who successfully prosecuted former Speaker Mike Hubbard.
According to well-placed sources, Marshall was the only district attorney that Bentley approached who promised he would take on Hart and Davis in exchange for the appointment as attorney general.
More individuals have come forward after the Bentley grand jury investigation concluded, confirming what APR had found after months of interviews.
The final agreement to give Marshall the attorney general’s job was reached the day before Bentley appointed former Attorney General Luther Strange to fill Jeff Sessions’ seat in the U.S. Senate.
According to Bentley’s official calendar — a copy of which is now kept at the Alabama Archives — he met with Marshall on Feb. 9 at 8 a.m. That was the day before Bentley’s press conference in which he appointed Strange to the Senate.
Continue reading below…
Hours after Marshall met with Bentley on Feb. 9, a high-ranking Bentley staffer commented to several people at the capitol, saying in effect, “We now have an attorney general who will get these rogue prosecutors at the AG’s office.”
On Feb. 9, just after the Strange press conference, Bentley began interviewing candidates for the AG’s position. Former deputy AG Alice Martin was his first interviewee. Marshall was his second, meeting with the governor for the second time in two days. Marshall was the only attorney general candidate to meet twice with Bentley, and he was the only candidate to meet with Bentley in the week leading up to the appointment.
The following day, on Friday, Feb. 10, 2017, after interviewing the remaining seven candidates, Bentley appointed Marshall to the position. A tweet from the governor’s Twitter account went out at 6:08 p.m., just four hours after the final interview for the job had ended.
“I was in the car driving home from my interview with Bentley when the tweet went out,” said a lawmaker who was considered a favorite for the AG slot. “I was shocked by his insincerity, he had already made his choice. We were just window dressing,” he said on background.
“We now have an attorney general who will get these rogue prosecutors at the AG’s office.”
The Attorney General’s Office denies agreeing to such a plan.
“The only assurance given to Robert Bentley by Attorney General Marshall at the time of his appointment was to enforce the law and uphold the Constitution,” a spokesman for Marshall said. “Any suggestion to the contrary is absurd and patently false.”
Marshall never launched an official investigation into Hart’s team or Davis as he promised Bentley, but what he has done is systematically undermine criminal cases and dismantle the special prosecutions unit by withholding assets and reassigning its staff to other cases unrelated to public corruption.
Marshall’s appointment is rooted in the state’s case against Republican Speaker of the House Mike Hubbard, who Davis and Hart would successfully prosecute on 12 counts of felony ethics violations.
Before and during his trial, Hubbard’s cronies and legal team repeatedly accused Hart and Davis of prosecutorial misconduct, an accusation that was rejected by Lee County Circuit Court Judge Jacob Walker III who served as the trial judge in Hubbard’s case.
During the lead-up to Hubbard’s conviction on felony ethics violations, Bentley and his special advisor, Rebekah Caldwell Mason, became obsessed with Hart, believing him to be more nefarious than Hubbard.
Mason and Bentley both shared their suspicions about Hart with a growing circle including staffers, state law-enforcement officers, federal investigators and even a journalist or two. Bentley was convinced that Hart was “out to get Becca,” his pet name for his married lover, Mason.
Mason confirmed Rane’s attempts to influence Bentley to remove Hart and Davis…
The couple’s fears were egged on by Hubbard’s friends and associates who wanted Bentley to launch an investigation into Hart and Davis during the Hubbard’s pre-trial hearings.
According to a source with direct knowledge of these and other incidents, powerful businessman Jimmy Rane, CEO of Great Southern Wood, approached Bentley on more than one occasion to encourage him to stop Hart’s investigation into Hubbard. Rane would be caught up in Hubbard’s illegal activities along with other powerful business interests who are now funding Marshall’s campaign for attorney general. Mason confirmed Rane’s attempts to influence Bentley to remove Hart and Davis from Hubbard’s case and appoint a special prosecutor, according to one of Mason’s confidants at the time.
Mason’s fear and hatred of Hart took many manifestations, according to two former staffers speaking on background, the most public of which was the firing of ALEA Secretary Spencer Collier in retaliation for cooperating with the Attorney General’s investigation into Hubbard.
Over time Mason’s torment increased, and she believed she and Bentley needed to destroy Hart before he could destroy them…
During the Hubbard investigation, Mason became convinced that Hart’s team had a “hit list” of individuals they would target after Hubbard’s trial. The so-called hit list, APR confirmed, never existed except in the minds of those who were being manipulated by Hubbard’s supporters.
The alleged hit list was not something Hart had drawn-up; instead, it was a scheme executed by Hubbard’s allies to alienate Hart and turn influential individuals against him. Even after Mason was assured that no such list existed, she grudgingly demurred choosing to believe the lie perpetrated by Hubbard’s backers.
Over time, Mason’s torment increased, and she believed she and Bentley needed to destroy Hart before he could destroy them, according to those who witnessed some of the couple’s discussions. According to members of the Bentley team, the governor would angrily fume about Hart constantly as his fears grew that Hart would come after “precious Becca.”
A former law-enforcement official confirmed to APR that not only did Bentley seek an investigation by local prosecutors to go after Hart and Davis, he also asked for help from the FBI, who found no reason to pursue Bentley and Mason’s fantasy accusations against Hart and Davis.
Mason was warned before Collier’s firing that she was being played by Hubbard’s allies, who wanted her to believe she was a target. She was also advised that her actions might very well lead to her being a suspect, according to an individual who cited several conversations he had with Mason.
At an introductory press conference, the following Monday after Bentley appointed him attorney general, Marshall said he had spent the previous two days in Montgomery meeting with the AG’s office staff, but said he was unaware if Bentley was under investigation by the office. If the governor were under investigation, Marshall said, he would be forced to recuse from that investigation.
Martin, who was still serving as chief deputy AG at the time, called Marshall’s comment untrue. She said she personally informed Marshall of the Bentley investigation and provided the new AG with a “briefing packet” outlining what had been done so far.
At the time, Bentley had already testified before a grand jury in Montgomery, and Strange, Martin and Hart were all present. That investigation was honing in on Bentley’s potential misuse of state funds to facilitate and cover up his inappropriate relationship with staffer Rebekah Mason.
That investigation would, of course, lead to Bentley pleading guilty to breaking campaign finance laws and resigning as governor.
More serious charges before the grand jury investigating Bentley were dropped after it found that state statute doesn’t cover a governor using law-enforcement to threaten and intimidate for political reasons. It also found that helping your girlfriend while being governor is not illegal under current law.
Opinion | Humane Alabama prisons would be a real surprise
Just some Christlike compassion and decent management. Getting either in Alabama’s prisons would be a huge surprise.
Nearly every day, there is a notification on my phone announcing that APR reporter Eddie Burkhalter has submitted yet another story on some new horror that has occurred within Alabama’s God-awful prison system.
A beating. A death. A suicide. Guards arrested. Guards accused of essentially murder. The Alabama Department of Corrections offering a lame-ass excuse for this death or that “suicide” or this drug overdose or that outright murder.
Every single day.
How he deals with it — listening to the pain and anguish of the prisoners and their family members — is simply unimaginable to me.
But because of his stories, and the work done by the ACLU’s Beth Shelburne, I know — and the readers of APR know — all too well of the violence and all around horrors that exist daily within Alabama’s prison system.
So, it was quite absurd to hear a few days ago that both the Alabama Department of Corrections and Attorney General Steve Marshall were “surprised” by a Department of Justice report that found the state’s prisons to be an absolute horror show, where beatings, suicides, murders and drug use are rampant.
The only people in those positions who would be “surprised” by such a report are idiots and liars. Marshall and Corrections Commissioner Jeff Dunn can decide where they fall.
The report from the Donald Trump DOJ, which is led by Bill Barr, was produced following a near-four year investigation into the prison system in the state, and it came on the heels of other federal reports that found similar issues.
The state is currently tied up in federal litigation over ADOC’s lack of health care and mental health care for prisoners. Testimony in that trial, highlighted by media, has brought damning details of the state’s prisons and the cruel and unusual punishment doled out within their walls.
At this point, the only people who don’t know that Alabama’s prisons are dark holes where violence, death and disease run rampant are those who don’t want to know.
You would think that such despicable stories of death and misery, in a state where Christian values reign and we profess a deep and unbreakable respect for the sanctity of life, would prompt public outrage. You would think our prisons would be governed by the Christian ideals of forgiveness and salvation.
You would be wrong.
Now, we could get into the many reasons — or, really, the one reason — why that is, but let’s not get bogged down in race or in why Christian repentance seems far less available the darker your skin.
Just know the prisons are awful and that their awfulness has never been a secret to anyone with a working brain and the ability to read.
That didn’t stop Marshall from grandstanding, however.
In a ridiculous press release, he declared that the state would not “be bullied” by the federal government into entering into a consent decree.
(I’d like to take a moment here to give proper respect to the federal bullying of Alabama over the years. Without it, we’d still have slavery, Jim Crow and Roy Moore-approved same-sex marriage laws.)
Marshall also, for some weird reason, tied the release of the report to the 2020 election, saying the state won’t be pressured into an agreement “conspicuously, 53 days before a presidential election.”
Yes, how dare the feds force us to treat humans like humans just 53 days before … other humans … go vote?
Hard to believe these guys aren’t getting the job done, isn’t it?
And they’re not. It doesn’t matter what happens — bad press, lawsuits, DOJ reports, threats from federal agencies — Alabama officials are NOT going to clean up our prisons. They’re not going to reduce overcrowding or provide proper care or hire and properly train enough corrections officers.
Not unless Alabama citizens hold them accountable.
And you should. Because the environment of any prison or detention center is set by the people who run it, not the inmates within it.
Instead of cesspools of violence and death, the prisons could be models of reform and humanity — where men and women are rehabilitated and provided life skills that reduce recidivism rates.
Isn’t it weird how such goals are not part of a $2 billion plan to build new prisons?
Over the weekend, a group of activists rallied in front of the governor’s mansion in Montgomery to protest that new prison plan. The Alabamians Who Care group wants massive reforms and a plan for better prisons that treat people more humanely.
That’s not impossible. Other countries and other states have done it. And it didn’t cost them $2 billion and federal intervention.
Just some Christlike compassion and decent management.
Getting either in Alabama’s prisons would be a huge surprise.
ALGOP rejects change that would have stripped voters of power to elect convention delegates
The 435-member Alabama Republican Executive Committee on Saturday voted to reject a proposed bylaws change that would have taken away the ability of Alabama Republican primary voters to elect the delegates to the Republican National Convention every four years. Under the proposal, the Executive Committee themselves would have picked all of the delegates.
The controversial measure was voted down 51 percent to 49 percent. This was a bylaws change so it required a two-thirds majority to pass. The vote was not even close.
The full Alabama Republican Executive Committee was holding its summer meeting at the Trussville Civic Center. Executive Committee members from every county in the state travel to the two Executive Committee meetings each year.
Claire Austin, who represents the Bullock County GOP, said that the committee would be taking away the people’s right to vote.
Joseph Fuller, who chairs the Bylaws Committee and represents the 3rd Congressional District on the ALGOP Steering Committee, argued for the change saying that having all of those delegate races on the ballot confuses primary voters and that 34 other states do not elect their convention delegates.
Fuller said the change was proposed by Elbert Peters of Madison County, who could not attend because of his health. One delegate from Jefferson County accused proponents of the change of trying to take away democracy. This same bylaw change was proposed at last year’s summer meeting and rejected by the Executive Committee then as well.
Republican primary voters on March 3 elected 47 delegates to the Republican National Convention in Charlotte. The Alabama Republican Executive Committee elected 47 alternate delegates in May. This year’s GOP convention has been canceled by President Donald Trump because of the growing danger of contracting COVID-19 by mixing so many people across the country into a packed convention hall.
The Executive Committee did approve a bylaws change allowing that in a declared state of emergency that a meeting of the Executive Committee could be done online.
Alabama Republican Party Chairman Terry Lathan said that she had talked to some members who were afraid to attend Saturday’s meeting because of the coronavirus threat.
There was a live feed so that members who did not attend the summer meeting in person could watch online, but because there was no provision in the bylaws for remote participation, they did not count toward achieving a quorum and could not vote on the proposed bylaws changes, resolutions or on selecting delegates to the electoral college.
Due to so many members fearing exposing themselves to the coronavirus and wrecks on I-65 slowing traffic, it was over 30 minutes into the event before the Executive Committee had a quorum and could conduct business. The traditional fundraising luncheon was canceled this year due to COVID-19 fears. Lathan said that there may be a virtual fundraiser later in the year to address the shortfall.
The Alabama Republican Executive Committee meets two times a year. The 21-member Republican Steering Committee conducts regular business for the party and meets much more frequently.
Jones calls for McConnell to bring the Senate back to work on bipartisan aid package
Alabama Sen. Doug Jones and two of his Democratic Senate colleagues — Nevada Sen. Jacky Rosen and New Hampshire Sen. Maggie Hassan — led 10 other senators in a letter asking Majority Leader Mitch McConnell of Kentucky to bring the Senate back into session and work through the weekend until Congress reaches a bipartisan deal to address the public health and economic crises caused by the COVID-19 pandemic.
“The ongoing COVID-19 pandemic in the U.S. has been relentless, bringing about a public health crisis and an economy teetering on the edge of catastrophe,” Jones and the other senators wrote. “Across the country, Americans are fearful and anxious as loved ones get sick, families go hungry, small businesses go under, and workers continue to go without pay. State and local coffers have run dry, tenants can’t afford the rent, state unemployment systems are overwhelmed, and over 150,000 Americans have died. Despite this, it has been over four months since the Senate passed a comprehensive relief package, and the relief we provided is running out.”
“In the circumstances we find ourselves, it is imperative that the Senate be in session through the remainder of this weekend and all of next week — working not on partisan nominations, but on bipartisan coronavirus relief for the American people,” the letter continues.
“With this in mind and with federal unemployment benefits having expired last night, we implore you to bring the Senate back into session this weekend and pass bipartisan legislation to help working Americans and families,” concluded the letter.
The House passed their Heroes Act in early May with little Republican input. Senate Republicans have proposed a $1 trillion coronavirus aid bill on top of the CARES Act and the other relief packages. Senate Democrats have criticized the Republican plan for not going far enough. Their proposal was for a $3 trillion aid bill.
Jones has been a vocal critic of McConnell’s delays in bringing a strong, bipartisan relief bill up for a vote. The original CARES Act had a costly provision that increased the amount of money that the unemployed could collect during the coronavirus economic shutdown. That bump up in benefits expired on Friday.
Millions of Americans, however, are still unemployed and are having to make mortgage and rent payments with dramatically less to spend. Senator Jones has called for a renewal of emergency unemployment benefits, as well as more relief for health care providers, small businesses and workers, schools, state departments of labor, and incentives for states to expand Medicaid.
He has also called for an extension of the federal eviction moratorium, and for the state of Alabama to renew its own eviction moratorium, which was lifted on June 1.
The federal government has enacted four pieces of legislation that provide relief to individuals, state and local governments and corporations that have been affected by the COVID-19 pandemic and the economic meltdown. These cost more than $2 trillion. To pay for all of this, the Treasury Department has ramped up borrowing.
According to a report by the Peter G. Peterson Foundation, since March 1, the United States Treasury has borrowed more than $3 trillion. Most of that increase has occurred since March 30, when the CARES Act was enacted.
Most of the new debt has been issued in the form of Treasury bills. T-bills mature in one year or less and account for 80 percent of the increase in debt since March 1. Treasury notes, which mature in 2 to 10 years, are 15 percent of the increase. Treasury bonds, which mature after more than 10 years, Treasury inflation-protected securities, and floating-rate notes, combine for the remaining five percent of the increase.
Fortunately, the government is paying very little interest on those new Treasury bills because interest rates dropped when the extent of the pandemic became clear and money fled risky investments like stocks and real estate trusts for security. For the 4-week bills that were issued on July 21, the government paid investors an interest rate of 0.11 percent. That is a considerable drop from the 1.60 percent interest rate that the government paid on the 4-week bills that were issued on Feb. 25 before the pandemic hit the U.S.
Treasury projects that they will borrow $677 billion in the third quarter.
The U.S. national debt is nearly $26.6 trillion — an all-time high — and the budget deficit is $3.8 trillion. Interest on the debt is costing taxpayers $337 billion annually, the fourth costliest federal program trailing Medicare and Medicaid at $1.3 trillion, Social Security at $1.08 trillion and national defense at $695 billion.
Jones is in a difficult re-election race with former Auburn head football coach Tommy Tuberville.
Sheriff Samaniego endorses Russell Bedsole in House District 49
Shelby County Sheriff John Samaniego has endorsed Russell Bedsole for Alabama House of Representatives District 49. The election is Tuesday. Bedsole, who has 21 years of experience with the Shelby County Sheriff’s Office, announced his candidacy for the vacant District 49 seat on June 2, 2020.
“As a longtime member of the Shelby County Sheriff’s Office, Bedsole knows firsthand how crucial law and order are to our nation,” said Shelby County Sheriff John Samaniego. “Bedsole will be a powerful voice in the Alabama House of Representatives. He will fight for the hardworking law enforcement officers and first responders serving our communities.”
The special primary election will be held Tuesday, Aug. 4, to fill the seat left vacant when Rep. April Weaver, R-Briarfield, joined President Donald Trump’s administration as a regional director of the Department of Health and Human Services. House District 49 includes portions of Bibb, Chilton and Shelby Counties.
Bedsole’s campaign said that during his time of service, Alabaster has benefited from positive economic growth, a first-class school system and a high quality of life.
Bedsole describes himself as a conservative Christian candidate, who “believes that life starts at conception, that the 2nd amendment should be protected, that our taxes need to be low and fair, and that our cities and counties need their fair share of infrastructure support.”
Bedsole says that he is dedicated to the service of the citizens of District 49 and standing up for conservative values and promised to make District 49 a great place to live for all of its citizens by working to improve District 49’s infrastructure and traffic flow, increased economic development and advancing school systems.
“I humbly ask for your vote on August 4th to allow me to serve District 49,” said Bedsole.
Bedsole has also been endorsed by Conservation Alabama.
In addition to Bedsole, Donna Strong, James Dean, Chuck Martin, Jackson McNeely and Mimi Penhale are all running in the special Republican primary on Tuesday, Aug. 4. If a runoff election is needed, it will be held on Tuesday, Sept. 1, 2020.
The eventual Republican nominee will face Cheryl Patton in the special general election on Tuesday, Nov. 17. There is no Democratic primary on Tuesday because Patton did not have a primary opponent. The winner will serve the remainder of April Weaver’s term, which ends in late 2022.
Polls open at 7 a.m. on Tuesday and close at 7 p.m. You must be a registered voter in HD49 in order to participate. You may only vote at the polling place you are assigned, and you must have a valid photo ID to participate in any Alabama election.