Connect with us


Testimony confirms Sen. Phil Williams lied about criminal investigation

Bill Britt



In sworn testimony given by disgraced former Gov. Robert Bentley, he affirms that State Sen. Phil Williams, R-Rainbow City, was under investigation for possible ethics violations related to consulting contracts he attained after becoming a state senator, as first reported by Alabama Political Reporter in 2016.

After APR exposed Williams’ potential legal woes, he undertook a media blitz to deny APR‘s reporting. Along the way, Williams duped several news organizations into printing his false and outrageous claims which now are proven to be deliberate lies. Williams deceived’s Paul Gattis,  Alabama Today’s Adam Powell and The Gadsden Times’ Lisa Savage and others into printing his defamatory and misleading statements about the state’s criminal investigation and APR.

During a six-hour deposition in the wrongful termination suit brought by former Alabama Law Enforcement Agency Secretary Spencer Collier,  Bentley recalls how Collier had informed him of the Williams criminal probe. Bentley also testifies that Williams came to him to discuss the investigation being carried out by Collier’s agents.

At the same time, Williams was seeking Bentley’s help, he was misleading the press and his colleagues about the investigation being conducted by ALEA with assistance from the Attorney General’s Special Prosecution Division led by Matt Hart.

The following is the transcript of Bentley’s testimony in which he is being questioned by Collier’s lawyer, Kenny Mendelsohn.

Q. Okay. Were you aware, not now but back in 2015-2016 before Spencer was fired, about an investigation of Senator Phil Williams?

A. Spencer told me about that.

Q. Do you know what the accusations were?


A. Yes, I do.

Q. What were those?

A. It has something to do with clients that he had secured. I think he had secured about 43 clients if I remember the correct number, and ALEA was investigating them probably at the request of Matt Hart, or it might have been some other reason. I don’t know.

Q. But you don’t know that it was Matt Hart, do you?

A. I don’t know for sure, but I think that we talked about that it was the Attorney General’s office that was working with Spencer.

Q. But the Attorney General’s office is fully capable of investigating crimes like that without ALEA?

MS. MAYS: Object to form.

A. Yes, but sometimes they don’t want to do it. They want somebody else to do it or do it in a different way.

Q. Do you know what the results of that investigation were?

A. I think that actually, Phil Williams knew about the investigation, and he was in my office at a certain time — I don’t remember the exact date, it was the early part of the year — and he told me that he had asked the Attorney General’s — not Attorney General, I’m sorry, ethics to investigate him, and he gave all the information to them, he said, and that they had cleared him.

Q. Did you have any other discussions with Phil Williams about the investigation of him?

A. It seemed like I did, but I can’t remember the exact date. But it wouldn’t be anything in detail.

Q. Did anybody else reach out to you about the investigation of Phil Williams, like any other senators, house members, anybody; anybody else contact you, outside of law enforcement, asking you about the Phil Williams incident?

A. I don’t remember that.

Q. What about David Standridge, do you know David?

A. I do know David.

Q. Did he ever meet with you about Phil Williams?

A. I don’t remember that.

The deposition makes clear that Collier informed then-Gov. Bentley about the Williams inquiry. Bentley also confirms Williams came to him about the investigation “in the early part of the year.”

Williams’ so-called consulting came to APR‘s attention in late December 2015, as part of its investigation into STARRS – the state’s much-flawed accounting system.

APR exposed the extent of Williams’ full list of clients on Jan. 4, 2016, showing that since becoming a senator, he had raked in contracts which, at a minimum, could total $146,000 to a maximum $265,000 per year, according to his report.

Senator Claims 43 Contracts are “Reoccurring Litigation Clients”

On Jan. 7, 2016, APR revealed that Williams was in fact a target in a criminal probe.

State Senator Under Investigation

However, on Jan. 11, 2016, The Gadsden Times, his hometown newspaper, reported, “He [Williams] said he has made a full inquiry at all levels of government and law enforcement and that revealed no evidence of any investigation.”

Despite his statements to The Gadsden Times, two days later, APR reported that State Law Enforcement had sent a letter to the State Ethics Commission confirming that Williams was under criminal investigation.

Law Enforcement Informs Ethics Commission Sen.Williams Under Criminal Investigation

Williams intervened with the Ethics Commission and would later boast that the commission cleared him of any wrong-doing.

Ethics Commission Executive Tom Albritton responded to APR‘s inquiry into the commissions roll in clearing Williams as Bentley suggested, saying, “We can’t investigate unless a complaint is filed with us and one was not filed with us.” said Albritton. “We CAN [his emphasis] self-generate one if 4 of our 5 commissioners vote to do that, but if they vote to self-generate, then they can’t sit in judgment of the Complaint,” he further explained. “The Alabama Supreme Court must appoint a special panel to hear the Complaint. The commission did not self-generate a complaint either.”

APR has requested any correspondence between the commission and Williams to substantiate his claim that the commission had cleared him.

Williams in 2016, told the Gadsden Times, “I took the unusual step of contacting the Alabama Ethics Commission on Friday and personally requested they conduct a full review of my law practice. At my own insistence, they have now received all five years of my client lists and will review them under seal.”

The case files into Williams’ alleged criminal activities was physically taken from Special Agent Jack Wilson by State Bureau of Investigations Director Gene Wiggins after Collier was fired. Those close to the investigation believe Bentley had the probe spiked to help Williams.

Firings Lead to Closing Criminal Cases

Williams is retiring from the Senate and still maintains his innocence.

Why Williams was never indicted remains an unanswered question for now, but finally his lies are exposed.



Alabama small business task force forms subcommittee on reopening state’s economy





Lieutenant Governor Will Ainsworth on Thursday announced that the Alabama Small Business Commission Emergency Task Force has formed a subcommittee on reopening the state’s economy and plans to present a plan to Gov. Kay Ivey and State Health Officer Dr. Scott Harris by April 17.

“Reopening Alabama’s economy and getting businesses back to work will not be like flipping a light switch, but it will more likely be accomplished in stages once the COVID-19 pandemic begins to ease,” Ainsworth said.  “The purpose of this subcommittee is to provide a roadmap to reopening the economy that balances the public’s health and safety with the need for small business owners and employees to resume operations.”

The subcommittee will consider issues like how to best ease restrictions on restaurant and store capacity guidelines and how to incorporate social distancing needs with increased commerce once officials decree that the worst of the COVID-19 threat has passed.

State Rep. Danny Garrett (R – Trussville) will serve as chairman of the subcommittee, and the other members include:

  • Senator Chris Elliott (R – Fairhope)
  • Senator Garlan Gudger (R – Cullman)
  • Representative Joe Lovvorn (R – Auburn)
  • Rosemary Elebash – National Federation of Independent Business, Alabama State Chair
  • Mindy Hanan – Alabama Restaurant and Hospitality Association, Executive Director
  • Katie Britt – Business Council of Alabama, CEO
  • Rick Brown – Alabama Retail Association, President
  • Tony Cochran of CK Business Solutions in Albertville
  • Stephen McNair of McNair Historic Preservation in Mobile

The 22-member commission is statutorily tasked with formulating “policies encouraging innovation of small businesses in the state” and advising the Department of Commerce in promoting small businesses within Alabama.  The state legislature placed the Alabama Small Business Commission under the authority of the Lieutenant Governor’s Office in 2018.

Continue Reading


Feds seizing needed supplies slowed state’s COVID-19 testing efforts

Chip Brownlee



Add Alabama to the list of states that have had trouble acquiring needed medical supplies from commercial vendors because the federal government intervened and took the supplies.

The federal government has been quietly seizing orders of medical supplies, protective gear and testing materials across the country, and Alabama has not been immune.

The federal government’s actions, blocking the shipment of those supplies, impeded the state’s ability to roll out widespread testing and added to supply shortages in the state, officials say.

The Alabama Department of Public Health told APR Thursday that several shipments of supplies from commercial vendors have been superseded by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services since the outset of the coronavirus pandemic in the state.

“It’s been happening all along,” said State Health Officer Scott Harris. “We had orders through about three different vendors, national vendors that we would normally use for medical supplies. They had accepted the orders and given us a ship date.”

But then the vendors called and canceled the orders.

“They say, you know, the inventory was acquired by HHS,” Harris said, referring to the Department of Health and Human Services.

The department and the Federal Emergency Management Agency have not publicly reported these acquisitions, according to the Los Angeles Times, nor has the administration detailed how these supplies are being used, when they decide to seize them and where the supplies are being rerouted to.


The first time was three weeks ago. The state placed an order for about four thousand nasopharyngeal swabs, the long Q-tip like swabs used to perform COVID-19 tests. The order was accepted, but before it could be shipped, HHS seized the supplies.

“That was one of the things that slowed our rollout of testing around the state because there were no supplies to be had,” Harris said.

Since then, the state and hospitals have been able to acquire supplies from other vendors, but the delays have hampered testing, putting Alabama behind other states like Louisiana. As of Thursday, Louisiana had tested nearly 90,000 people for the virus. The number includes most commercial tests.

The main issue facing the state has not been the so-called “test kits” or even the state lab’s capacity to run tests.

“We’ve had days where we thought we were going to be out of reagent, and we’ve wondered if we were going to have to hold off testing, but we haven’t had to stop,” Harris said. “We’ve had some just-in-time deliveries that we weren’t sure were coming.”

The real issue has been the swabs needed to collect samples. Hospitals and health officials across the state, from Huntsville to Mobile, have at one point or another reported severe shortages of nasopharyngeal swabs.

“We’re bidding against every other state in the country, and in some cases, we’re bidding against health care facilities here in our own state who are doing their own testing,” Harris said of the process of acquiring swabs and other supplies.

ADPH and hospitals have been able to get more of those supplies, and Alabama has slowly ramped up testing as a result. But it has not been easy. “Getting those swabs and viral transport media has really been the rate-limiting step for most of our testing clinics,” Harris said.

As of Thursday, the state has tested about 20,000 people, nearly twice the number reported five days ago on April 4. Testing has been increasing over the past week and a half, Harris said.

More have been tested, but it’s hard to know exactly how many because not all commercial labs are reporting the number of negative tests they conduct. Harris said the state has asked the commercial labs to report those numbers, but some have been slow to do so.

Alabama has also had trouble receiving other types of needed medical supplies like ventilators and personal protective equipment. Some of the shipments seized by the federal government have been personal protective equipment intended to refill dwindling supplies at some of the state’s harder hit hospitals, nursing homes and other providers, according to Dr. Donald Williamson, the president of the Alabama Hospital Association.

Though no hospital has run out of PPE, some have been running low, Williamson said. But hospitals have been forced to take unusual measures to conserve supplies, particularly the N95 masks that offer the most protection to health care workers treating COVID-19 patients.

The city of Montgomery in late March received 28 cases of protective masks from the strategic national stockpile, according to the Montgomery Advertiser. When the city opened the shipment, about 5,800 of the masks had dry rot and an expiration date of 2010.

The difficulties in the supply chain have also affected the state’s ability to acquire new ventilators. Harris told APR on Friday that the state asked the federal government for 500 ventilators, and for 200 of them to be delivered urgently. HHS indicated that it would not fulfill the request anytime soon, and that the state could expect additional ventilators only if a dire need was expected within 72 hours.

So Alabama, like a number of states, is being forced to try to source ventilators on its own through the private market, where thousands of hospitals, all the other states and countries all over the world are trying to do the same, causing prices to skyrocket.

Alabama has placed an order for 250 more ventilators, and that order has been accepted, but it has not shipped yet, Harris said.

“We’re just not sure when they’re going to get here,” Harris said. “But we will need them in the next 14 days.”

In the meantime, Alabama has shipped about a dozen out-of-date ventilators to California for refurbishment. About half of those have been returned and distributed to hospitals based on their need. The state has also added to its ventilator capacity by retrofitting anesthesia machines and veterinary ventilators for use on those infected with the virus. Even though the state has added about two hundred new ventilators into service, the usage rate of ventilators has remained about the same. As of April 8, at least 101 people have required mechanical ventilation in Alabama for COVID-19. The number is expected to rise in the next weeks.

In the meantime, the state has had trouble getting ventilators from private vendors because the components needed to produce them have been redirected by the federal government to Ford and GM, who have been ordered to manufacture ventilators in mass quantities.

“They have had first-choice at these parts,” Harris said. “So the people who normally make ventilators can’t get those parts, which slows down delivery for all of us who’ve gone through the normal channels to get them where we would normally get them.”

Williamson and Harris said the state and its hospitals, which are already facing a cash crunch, have been forced to pay inflated prices for needed supplies because demand is high and supply is short.

“Some of our folks are seeing prices substantially higher than they normally have for PPE, specifically N95 masks. Some of it is supply and demand, and some of it is people taking advantage of an unfortunate situation,” Williamson said.

The state has been able to identify supply to help support hospitals who are sourcing their own, too, but the costs are exorbitant and a majority of the “vendors” offering to supply the state with supplies are counterfeit.

“You know, you would normally pay 60 or 70 cents for a mask,” Harris said. “These offers are typically $5 or $6 per mask now. I’ve seen some are asking for $10 or whatever, which is truly outrageous.”

The governor’s office, the Department of Commerce and the attorney general’s office have been helping the Department of Public Health source needed supplies.

“We’re doing our best to source those any way we can,” Harris said.

Harris and Williamson both said PPE supply and ventilator capacity, at least right now, appear to be in decent shape.

“I’m feeling better about ventilators,” Williamson said. “But it would always be nice to have more. With the surge we’re expecting, we seem to be okay. We’ve only had a couple of instances where we’ve had to try to assist and help move ventilators from one hospital to another hospital, but we’ve been able to do that and no one has gone without a ventilator who needed one.”

But the Department of Public Health expects a rise in hospitalizations over the next two weeks that could add further strain the state’s health care system.

“Let’s see what happens over the next week, but for today, we are much better prepared than we would have been, frankly, a few months ago,” Williamson said.

Continue Reading


400 Alabama health care workers and 155 nursing home staff, residents positive for COVID-19

Chip Brownlee



Nearly 400 health care workers and 90 long-term care facility employees have tested positive for the novel coronavirus.

The Alabama Department of Public Health said Thursday that at least 393 health care workers, 90 long-term care facility employees and 65 long-term care facility residents have tested positive. Health care workers includes those who work at hospitals or doctor’s offices.

As of 2 p.m. on Thursday, the state had confirmed 2,700 cases of the virus. At least 70 people have died after testing positive for the virus in Alabama, of those 48 have been fully investigated and verified by ADPH epidemiologists.

The number of confirmed cases among health care workers has grown significantly this week. Alabama Gov. Kay Ivey said Friday at a press conference that 200 health care workers in the state had contracted COVID-19. By Tuesday, that number increased to 315.

The number of long-term care facility residents has increased from 51 on Tuesday to 65 now, adding to concerns that the virus is widespread among the state’s nursing homes and long-term care facilities, which are considered extremely vulnerable to the virus.

At least 62.5 percent of the 48 verified deaths have been among those 65 years old or older.

At least 333 people have been hospitalized with the virus in Alabama since March 13, but the number is surely higher because of delays in investigating each case.  Of those who have been hospitalized, 153 have required treatment in an intensive care unit and of those, 101 have required mechanical ventilation.

Nurses, doctors, hospitals and the Alabama Department of Public Health have said that a nationwide shortage of personal protective equipment has not spared Alabama.


Alabama Hospital Association President Dr. Donald Williamson told APR Tuesday that some hospitals in the state have severe shortages of N95 masks, with some hospitals reporting that they have only a days of supplies left.

So far, he said, no hospitals have run out of supplies yet, but some have had to take serious measures to conserve their masks.

State Health Officer Scott Harris told APR Thursday that the state is being bombarded with fake offers to provide PPE, mainly from foreign companies claiming to be able to supply the state.

Harris said the state has been able to identify supply to help support hospitals who are trying to source their own, too, but the costs are exorbitant.

“You know, you would normally pay 60 or 70 cents for a mask,” Harris said. “These offers are typically $5 or $6 per mask now. I’ve seen some are asking for $10 or whatever, which is truly outrageous.”


Continue Reading


Mobile County jail inmates, officers test positive for COVID-19

Eddie Burkhalter



The Mobile County Sheriff’s Office says six inmates at the county jail and even more correctional officers have tested positive for COVID-19, according to WKRG, which broke the story on Thursday.

Attempts to reach the sheriff’s office’s public information officer wasn’t immediately successful Thursday, but WKRG reported that the sheriff’s office confirmed that 6 inmates have tested positive for the virus and more than 6 officers also tested positive. The news station reported that the sheriff’s office was working to get an exact number of those who tested positive for the virus.

Two Alabama Department of Corrections employees have tested positive, but no inmates in state prisons had confirmed cases as of Tuesday, the last day ADOC had updated testing numbers.

This story will be updated.

Continue Reading



The V Podcast