Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Featured Opinion

Opinion | Hoover ISIS bride should face the U.S. justice system

Hoda Muthana should face the U.S. justice system.

Let’s get that out of the way right up front. The young woman from Hoover who left the country a few years ago to join the Islamic State, or ISIS, should not be granted free entry into the country again simply because she’s now realized that she made a mistake.

Because as mistakes go, that’s a doozy. Right up there with paid two guys to beat me up and pour bleach on me so I could fake a hate crime and get paid more by the TV show I’m on.

Muthana screwed up. Royally. And she should face the consequences of her actions, and she should have American law enforcement and intelligence agencies thoroughly investigate her. And she should serve a lengthy jail sentence, if those entities and the courts determine one is warranted.

But we have to let her back in.

I’m sorry, but we do. She’s an American, and in America, we believe in a system of justice that determines adequate punishment for those who violate our laws and Constitution.

Muthana should be no different.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

If we can find a place in our justice system for a man who shot dead people worshipping in a church service or those who shot dead young kids in a school, then we should be able to find a place for Muthana.

Honestly, I would think the people of Alabama would be most understanding about this. Particularly those who continue to fight to preserve monuments to men who led a revolt against the U.S. — men who turned their backs on their county over an awful, horrifying cause.

Seems like we should know better than anyone that sometimes folks just get twisted up and make awful decisions.

Particularly when religion is involved.

How many dumb and downright terrible things have occurred in Alabama in the name of religion?

Our ancestors used it to justify slavery. It was used to justify Jim Crow laws. I’ve heard it used to defend not providing welfare to poor people. It was used a few years ago to justify a terrible anti-immigration bill.

And let’s be honest, religion is truly at the heart of wanting to keep Muthana out of the country. Our fear of Islam — particularly “radical Islam” — will lead us to violate any portion of the Constitution.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

And that’s exactly what several state and national politicians are doing right now — vowing to prevent Muthana from re-entering the U.S. to stand trial.

Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, at the direction of the president, led the way. Alabama Congressman Gary Palmer agreed with them.

“Those who betray the country and fight for ISIS have to suffer the consequences for their actions. Secretary Pompeo has expressed that she has no legal basis to return to the U.S. and I agree with him. She forfeited the privileges of citizenship when she provided aid to radical extremists seeking to kill Americans,” Palmer told

Except, that’s not how it works. You can’t forfeit your citizenship by making dumb choices.

And in America, we determine the loss of citizenship through our court system.

Look, the courts may determine that Muthana fought in a foreign army or in some way renounced her citizenship or that she committed an act of treason against the country.

If so, bye, Muthana.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

But one of the things that makes this greatest country is that our court system — flawed as it might be — is the answer to these questions. It has to be.

If we allow fear and anger to push us into abandoning our system of justice, we all lose.


Josh Moon is an investigative reporter and featured columnist at the Alabama Political Reporter with years of political reporting experience in Alabama. You can email him at [email protected] or follow him on Twitter.

More from APR


The bill by Rep. Susan DuBose excludes transgender individuals from being defined by state law as the gender with which they identify.


Even today, few will remember the name Günter Guillaume.


The bill would make faking an abduction a felony punishable by up to 10 years in prison.


Wilkins said he will donate $10,000 to an Alabama veterans’ charity of Palmer’s choosing if Palmer will agree to a debate.