Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Featured Opinion

Opinion | Montgomery is broken: A cautionary tale for the rest of Alabama

The downtown Montgomery skyline. STOCK

There was a mayoral forum on Wednesday night in Montgomery, where the 11 candidates for mayor presented their strategies for saving the town and restoring law and order. 

It is hopeless. 

Chances are, if you don’t live in Montgomery, you don’t care much about who is elected mayor or about the everyday problems that plague the city. But you should, if only because the current state of Montgomery is a cautionary tale for every city and town in Alabama. 

Montgomery is the story of what can go wrong when you do wrong. It is the story of how racism and indifference can forever scar a town. It is a story of the way racism slowly morphs into classism and destroys any city. 

Because Montgomery became what it is today by doing exactly the sorts of things people in towns all across Alabama are trying, as they form breakaway cities and breakaway school districts and isolate communities and stifle public transportation and generally insulate the upper-middle class-and-above sections of town from anyone and everyone beneath that social standing. 

Montgomery did all of that long ago — in the 1950s and 60s — and then just kept sequestering and segregating and isolating right up to today. 

Which is why the town is hopeless. And why every candidate who spoke on Wednesday night doesn’t have a prayer of fixing the issues that plague that city — the crime, the stupid violence, the broken school system, the unwillingness of businesses to locate there, the citizens fleeing to any other city at the first opportunity. 

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Now, don’t get me wrong, Montgomery could be fixed. It would take time and devotion and lots and lots of money to do it, but it could be fixed. 

It won’t be fixed. Because fixing it would require a whole lot of people who have played a role in breaking that city admitting that they were wrong and then forking over cash to pay for the repairs. 

They’ll never do it. 

So, the best we can hope for, I think, is to learn from Montgomery. To take its lessons and its current-day examples and prevent other cities from suffering similar fates. 

And the most important lesson is this: The education of ALL CHILDREN is the key to your city’s success. 

Pay for it now. Or your children and grandchildren will pay tenfold. 

The white fathers and grandfathers of Montgomery did not do this. Instead, in the 1950s, faced with the forced integration of public schools, the wealthy in Montgomery essentially set up their own segregated school systems by establishing private schools. 

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

At one point, Montgomery had more private schools than any other city in America. All so little white kids — rich, white kids — could avoid attending schools with black kids. 

Over time, thanks to various zoning issues, the placement of an Interstate, racist mortgage lending practices and sketchy public transportation routes, that racism slowly morphed into classism. Because poorer whites couldn’t move out of the “bad” neighborhoods fast enough, as Montgomery’s white, upper-middle class slowly drifted east. 

And so, what was left behind were public schools and neighborhoods filled with poor people. 

With poverty comes the crimes of opportunity, the drug use and drug sales and the poor academic performances of students who live tough lives and receive little guidance. 

Gangs and drugs and petty street crime become a way of life. And every day the violence slowly and steadily increases, and spreads, as angry children who are desperate to achieve anything in life embrace the goals of gang leaders and criminals. 

None of this was too big of a problem, of course, when the violence and crime and death were mostly contained within the black/poor communities of Montgomery. But today, after generations have been denied a decent education and have turned to the streets to make a life, it can’t be contained. 

Now there are daily shootings. A couple of weeks ago, there was a full-fledged gunfight on a street near several popular restaurants. On Thursday night, there was a shooting near the campus of Alabama State University that left two dead and three more injured. 

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Every year, Montgomery’s murder rate hovers around a record high. And even with the cops in the town fixing crime stats, the crime rates are atrocious. 

But this is the penance for Montgomery’s sins. For believing that you could throw away thousands of young kids, simply because they were black or brown or poor or some combination, and deny them hope and love and a dream, and that there would be no consequences for it. 

And it will be the penalty for any community that is heartless enough to take such actions. 

Eventually, you will run out of schemes. You will run out of places to run. 

If you doubt this, just remember Montgomery.


Josh Moon is an investigative reporter and featured columnist at the Alabama Political Reporter with years of political reporting experience in Alabama. You can email him at [email protected] or follow him on Twitter.

More from APR

Featured Opinion

A whole bunch of people seem to think Montgomery's problems fell from the sky last month. They've been building for decades.


In Alabama, bail bonds allow pretrial release, but recent reforms aim to address financial burdens and safety.


This is the first publicly known action from an Alabama university responding to the state's new anti-DEI law.


Birmingham reclaims its spot from Montgomery as the second most populous city in the state of Alabama.