APLS board elects Amy Minton chair, signaling continued support for court-challenged rule

Minton has been a leading champion on the APLS board for policies that restrict books with transgender or sexual content.

Amy Minton
Amy Minton

John Wahl’s tenure as chairman of the APLS board has ended, with the remaining board members present at the board’s Thursday meeting electing Amy Minton as the new chair moving forward.

Wahl is leaving the board altogether in January to serve as lieutenant governor, though Thursday’s vote would have been necessary regardless as Wahl had already served two consecutive terms and could not continue in the role of chair.

“I am thrilled, honored and humbled to be chair,” Minton said in an interview with the media following the meeting. “I look forward to working with all the public libraries. Reading has always been a passion of mine.”

Minton has been Wahl’s right hand in advancing new state agency rules that bar children and youth sections from shelving content that includes transgender depictions or certain sexual descriptions. The rule goes beyond the relocation of books and outright bans libraries receiving state aid from purchasing such books designed for minor audiences moving forward.

That rule is now being challenged in federal court by three authors and by Read Freely Alabama, the grassroots organization that has been vocally challenging the policy at every turn. The lawsuit is similar to one brought against the Autauga-Prattville Public Library two years ago, claiming the rule violates the First Amendment, is overbroad and vague. The Prattville lawsuit has been in limbo awaiting a ruling on a motion for preliminary injunction.

The APLS board met in executive session at the end of its meetings with a handful of attorneys from the attorney general’s office to discuss the pending litigation. Wahl said the lawsuit was served to board members yesterday, which should trigger a deadline of 21 days for a response. That response will be handled by the attorney general’s office.

In addition to the leadership change on the board, the agency is also restating its search for a director after a majority of board members found Kelyn Ralya to be unsatisfactory as director. Ralya assumed the position after the termination of Nancy Pack last year.

Board members emphasized that they are completely satisfied with Ralya in her previous position as an assistant director handling the federal grant process—of which the agency allocated about $1 million for various library projects across the state on Thursday. Ralya is not being terminated and is still serving in the director role while a new director is sought. If a new director is brought in, Ralya will simply return to her assistant director role.

Board members didn’t say exactly why Ralya’s performance failed to satisfy, but there has been friction over the past few months after the board created a position that amounted to a compliance czar for its new state aid requirements. While the board could create the appointed position, it was not allowed to fill the position itself like with other employees—it needed Ralya to cooperate and make the appointment. That’s something that Ralya declined to do at the previous meeting and again declined to do Thursday.

Pennie Broussard, director of Human Resources at the agency, said that while Ralya had complete discretion over whether to fulfill the role, not doing so was viewed as an act of insubordination by the board.