Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?


Accountability Act: Price Ruling, Lobbyist, Racism and More

By Bill Britt
Alabama Political Reporter

MONTGOMERY— Montgomery Circuit Court Judge Charles Price once again upheld the temporary restraining order prohibiting the transmission of the School Accountability Act to Governor Bentley. For the last two days, the leadership the GOP-controlled legislature has fought to vacate Price’s order. Wednesday, in the opinion issued by Price he wrote, “‘The language of Rule 21 brings it within the constitutional mandate of Section 61 of the Constitution of Alabama 1901, which states . . . ‘no bill shall be so altered or amended on its passage through either house as to change its original purpose.’”
The court has set a date for a full hearing on March 15.
After the Judge’s ruling a testy Phillip Bryan, Chief of Staff for Senate President Pro Temp Del Marsh, barked a statement at reporters as he hurried from the courtroom saying, “We will take this to the Supreme Court, this is an unprecedented case of judicial interference in the legislative process.”
The GOP leadership is in a great rush to get the School Accountability Act before the Governor because there is mounting pressure for the bill to be scrapped. The School Board Association has voiced grave misgiving about the bill as well as Tommy Bice, Superintendent of the Alabama Department Education and others.
The bill, passed under a cloak of secrecy, has caused a firestorm in the press and in the halls of the StateHouse because many feel the legislative process was highjacked.
Even the Governor has said that the bill most likely would not have passed if it had not been kept a secret from members of the legislature and public.
Now, the same men are determined to bypass the judicial process and bring the case before the Supreme Court skirting Judge Price and the Alabama Court of Appeals.
Marsh’s office issued a statement saying that Judge Price’s ruling was “judicial activism at its worst.” House Speaker Mike Hubbard said the ruling was a “ridiculous unconstitutional overreach” and a “patently political ruling.”
The words of Hubbard and Marsh are tame next to the GOP echo chamber on blogs and talk radio, where Judge Price has been called a “clown” a “savage” and more. Just stopping short of the “N-word,” some in the so-called right have shown disrespect for a man who has received the prestigious Profiles in Courage award.
What started as a school flexibility bill was turned into something totally different, in conference committee, no one denies that fact. In his opinion Judge Price said, “The court finds that this bill was changed from its original purpose.”
Attorney’s for the AEA said that the Legislature could return to the StateHouse at anytime and introduce the new School Accountability Act and there would be nothing they could do to stop it.
However, the GOP leadership knows that they could never keep their members in line to vote for the new bill now that its content has been made known. One GOP Senator said, “The problem is that many of our members don’t have the guts to man-up and vote for this bill, we are a supermajority and can pass any bill we want, but there are too many weak knees nellies.”
Marsh and Hubbard have cried out about special interest groups having too much influence. The day the new bill passed out of conference committee, special interest were in the room. They consisted of the AEA, plus republican lobbyist Dax Swatek and Tim Howe who represent the multi-million dollar virtual learn group, Learning Through Sports, a company originally bankrolled by Mike Hubbard. Swatek and Howe along with their partners John Ross and David Azbell took over the Learning Through Sports lobbying job from convicted felon Jarrod Massey. John Ross former ALGOP executive director under Mike Hubbard, Azbell who wrote Hubbard’s book Storming the StateHouse along with their partners are even now under a cloud of a Grand Jury investigation into public corruption.
Also present was Andy Solon, State Director for Studentsfirst, the countries largest lobbying group for charter school’s. One of StudentsFirst’s largest contributors is former Enron executive and Texas billionaire John Arnold. Arnold is also one of President Obama’s biggest fundraisers. Questions have been raised as to why the democrat-funded group StudentsFirst have been apart of the ongoing story of the bait and switch but Hubbard and Marsh refuse to speak with reporters from the Alabama Political Reporter.
As of this report the Supreme Court of Alabama has yet to speak.

Written By

Bill Britt is editor-in-chief at the Alabama Political Reporter and host of The Voice of Alabama Politics. You can email him at [email protected] or follow him on Twitter.



With more than half of his sentence remaining, Hubbard's legal team filed a motion on Sept. 10 requesting early release.

Featured Opinion

"Justice should never be meted out with favoritism, but it was in Hubbard's case."


The court ruled the state had failed to provide evidence that VictoryLand posed any real threat to the peace.


June 1 had been the deadline to conclude contracts with private prison developers on building three new prisons.